
A few weeks ago, I wrote about my
top 10 favorite sandwiches in America, and asked you to share your picks. We got more than 50 responses, from shrimp po'boys in New Orleans to cheesesteaks in Philadelphia to Vietnamese bahn mi in Portland to something called the "Sloppy Irishman" in Ohio. I compiled the picks into this list, grouped
very loosely by type (Italian next to Italian, seafood with seafood etc). So thanks for all the awesome suggestions! I don't know about you, but I feel a cross-country sandwich road trip coming on...
1. Cheesesteak from
Primanti Brothers in Pittsburgh, PA
2. Cheesesteak from
Pat's King of Steaks in Philadelphia, PA
3. Steak Chacarero, spicy, at
Chacarero in Boston, MA
4. Pambazo at
Autentica in Portland, OR
5. Cemita at
Cemitas Pueblo in Chicago, IL
6. Midnight Cuban at Paseo in Seattle, WA (two votes)
7. Cuban from
Dave's Fresh Pasta in Somerville, MA
8. Milano from
The Italian Store in Arlington, VA
9. The Otto at
Fraboni's in Madison, WI (two votes)
10. Porchetta sandwich from
Porchetta in New York, NY
11. Italian Beef, wet, at
Al's Beef in Chicago, IL
12. Godmother from
Bay Cities Italian Deli and Bakery in Santa Monica, CA
13. Veal and Pepper at
California Sandwiches in Toronto, ON
14. The Special at
Gandel's Liquors in Washington, DC
15. Muffaletta at
Napoleon House in New Orleans, LA
16. Oyster or Shrimp (or Oyster and Shrimp) Po-Boy at Domilese's Po-Boys in New Orleans, LA
17. Shrimp Po-Boy at The Galley, Metairie, LA
18. Ipswich Clam Burger at
Bigelow's in Rockville Centre, NY
19. Lobster Roll at
The Red Barn in Ghent, NY (two votes, not counting mine)
20. Grilled Grouper at
Harbor Docks in Destin, FL
21. Tuna Niçoise at the
Bread Peddler in Olympia, WA
22. Jambon Beurre from
Farmstead Lunch in Providence, RI
23. Monte Cristo from
Milton's in Del Mar, CA
24. Monte Cristo from the
HMS Bounty in Los Angeles, CA
25. Pork Bun from
Momofuku Ssam Bar in New York, NY
26. Baoguette Bahn Mi at
Baoguette in New York, NY
27. Saigon Bacon Banh Mi at Best Baguette in Portland, OR
28. BLT on Rye at
Zingerman's Delicatessen in Ann Arbor, MI
29. BLB at
Meat Cheese Bread in Portland, OR
30. The Fat Darrell, various locations around
Rutgers University in New Brunswick, NJ
31. Sloppy Irishman at The Irish Pub in Massillon, OH
32. Parmageddon at
Melt Bar and Grilled in Lakewood, OH
33. Beef on Weck at
All Star Sandwich Bar, Cambridge, MA
34.
Maid Rite at various locations in Wisconsin and Iowa
35. Roast Pork at DiNic's in Philadelphia, PA
36. Pork Shoulder at
Smoky Jon's in Madison, WI
37. Pork and Fries at
Earl's Sandwiches in Arlington, VA
38. Pork and Beef BBQ at
LC's BBQ in Kansas City, MO
39. Burnt Ends at
Blue Ribbon BBQ in Newton, MA
40. Garlic and Thyme Roasted Pork at
Watershed in Decatur, GA
41. Fried Chicken Sandwich at
Bakesale Betty in Oakland, CA
42. Coney Dog with cheese and onions at
Skyline Chili in Cincinnati, OH
43. Patty Melt at Mic Duck's, Chicago, IL
44. Crown Burger at Crown Burgers in Salt Lake City, UT
45. Reuben Sliders at
Kenny and Zuke's in Portland, OR
46. Pastrami on Rye at
Katz's Delicatessen in New York, NY (four votes)
47. Jewish Hoagie at Koch's Deli in Philadelphia, PA
48. Corned Beef Special at Hymie's Deli in Philadelphia, PA
49. The Natte at Hungarian Deli in New York, NY
50. Market Fried Egg sandwich at
Gateway Market in Des Moines, IA
51. Grilled Vegetable at Village Baker in Bend, OR
52. Five Easy Pieces at Littlejohn's in Charlottesville, VA
53. Chicken Salad Sandwich at
Tomato Jam Cafe in Asheville, NC
54. Fern's Problem Solver at Hi Rise in Cambridge, MA