Some people have to avoid butter in their diets and to the die-hard butter fans, this seems
like a sad thing. There are many valid reasons to do this, though, such as a doctor's orders to reduce cholesterol
intake. There are also some people who simply prefer the taste of margarine, but though it might make an acceptable
substitute on toast, margarine can't really compare to butter in baked goods - particularly in a butter cookie. Or can
it? The Wall Street Journal baked up a few batches to find out.
The butter cookies made with real butter, the Land O'Lakes Ultra Creamy, came out on top. Land O' Lakes stick margarine came in second place, with a reasonable approximation of the taste and appearance of the real cookie. Unfortunately, the Land O' Lakes tub margarine did not fare as well, and though it had a similar texture to butter, the taste was nowhere near the real thing. Promise stick margarine did not do well, either, producing a cookie with little butter flavor.
I have actually had good results using Earth Balance "buttery spread" when baking, but the clear the solution is to stick to butter - not margarine - when it comes to baking.
