Photo: Elizabeth Hait, AOL
"Peanut butter and chocolate just got better!" claims the promo for the new Snickers Peanut Butter Squared campaign. But did they? We Slashfooders ran out for a bag of the new candy bars (each a 1.78-ounce square) as soon as they hit the store shelves today. I mean, it's a Snickers, the classic chocolate bar. What's to improve?
Turns out, not much. "I'm not getting the peanut," said one editor. "The nougat flavor is overwhelming." "I wanted more peanut butter," said our resident candy fanatic. "I feel like I've been duped!" And our resident candy curmudgeon said, "It's kind of a mess."
The verdict? Keep it classic, Snickers, with just the peanuts (singular) or up the ante on the peanut butter. But we still love you.


Live from Microsoft's New Generation Xbox event!
Xbox Reveal liveblog on Joystiq
Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Xbox One architecture panel liveblog!
Selena Gomez Leaving Justin Bieber's House: Booty Call Rumors Swirl
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight














1-04-2011 @2:51PM sushi18 said... I just tried a peanut butter Snickers last night...and I thought it was amazing! the perfect amount of peanut butter! if they had added anymore, I might as well have gotten a Reece's...It was still a Snickers bar, but with PLENTY of gooey peanut butter. You people don't have any taste buds if you think it's bad.
Reply
1-04-2011 @4:06PM Patty said... OMG..(as the kids do today) we had our first new Snickers today and both my hubby & I thought WTG... keep 'em in the Snickers line-up.. tytyty
1-04-2011 @4:59PM Judy said... We once saw a snickkers ad that was very gender bias against men. We have not nor shall we ever eat another snikkers bar until they retract that false impression and gender bias against men slant.
1-04-2011 @5:16PM Al Schrader said... So they like take the crunchy, delicious peanuts & grind them into ? Can I have the one with the real peanuts ?....Al-
1-05-2011 @4:02AM Jan said... It's awful! Tastes like dusty ... something, not sure what, just dusty and tasteless. I'll never buy them again. Gross. I agree taste is very subjective so undoubtedly some folks will like it, but not me, that's for sure. It was weeks ago and I'm still feeling queezy when I think of it.
1-04-2011 @3:19PM Peggie said... Haven't seen it in the stores here yet. Will try it for sure though when they do! Snickers is my favorite.
Reply
1-04-2011 @3:27PM sunny said... If something ain't broke, why do they feel the need to fix it?????
Reply
1-04-2011 @4:58PM shirley fauber said... Im so glad that it doesnt have peanuts in it, I have diverticulitis and can not eat peanuts, so Im really thrilled about it. I havent had one yet, but I always loved the original snicker but had to stop eating because of the peanuts, so I know it will be great, Thanks
Reply
1-04-2011 @5:02PM Hattie Crabtree said... I have diverticulosis and still can eat nuts.Anything with choc and nuts or choc and peanut butter,I'll eat it!!!!!
1-19-2011 @6:18PM Sue said... Shirley, I only had one bar, but it looked as if it also had chopped up peanuts as well as the peanut butter. You might want to check before eating it if you can't eat peanut pieces.
2-04-2011 @5:15PM liz said... It DOES have peanuts in it, as well as peanut butter.
1-04-2011 @5:27PM John said... I bought a 52 ounce bag at COSTCO in Reno over a week ago. Big mistake and unless they change the formula I won't be buying again. I expected to taste peanut butter. I agree, there is not much taste of peanut butter at all.
Reply
1-04-2011 @5:33PM carol said... Judy........We don't really care whether you buy another Snickers or not but you do need to learn how to spell "Snickers".
Reply
1-04-2011 @6:28PM Richard said... During the holidays, i had the privilege of being a food demonstrator at a major food warehouse.I hande out 1200 Snickers Peanut Butter Fun Size snack samples. The response was overwhelming. The size was well liked, snack size. The peanut butter taste was just enough to satisfy. It added a little ting to the already liked , original Snickers. I strongly disagree with your quote,"one Editor". I feel it was not meant to be a peanut butter candy bar, just a peanut butter tease !
Reply
1-04-2011 @11:20PM Lassie said... Well, of course the response was "overwhelming", you were handing out FREE DANDY! DUH!
I'll try one of these if I can find it. How hard can it be? To find it?
And peanut butter and chocolate? OMG! How novel! I MUST try pb and chocolate!
(blah. Can't the candy factories come up with something besides peanut butter and chocolate, peanut butter and chocolate, peanut butter and chocolate......I'd rather spend more and buy some GOOD candy.
1-04-2011 @6:29PM Voshna said... I haven't liked any of the Snickers variations. I really like the original. I agree with Sunny- if it ain't broke.
But, y'all have to try the new Reese's peanut butter cups "minis". They are the perfect size to pop and the perfect ratio of chocolate to peanut butter. I find that the full size Reese's are too peanut buttery and way too sweet. I used to like the "fun size" and would keep them in the freezer- but there was still too much packaging. The mini's are in a bag and pour like m&m's, but don't keep them in your hand, they would melt in a heart beat! if only they would last in your hand long enough.
Please slashfood editor- you must try these tiny morsels. I may have to find a 12 step group to cure my new addiction. Care to join me!
Reply
1-04-2011 @7:09PM GJB said... About two years ago, there was a Peanut Butter Snickers that was just peanut butter, peanuts and chocolate. They really should bring that one back.
Reply
1-04-2011 @11:09PM GREG2305 said... Snickers and peanut butter, way to go Snickers !
Or so I thought, peanut butter taste like Sh**.
Reply
1-04-2011 @7:27PM Megan said... Oh my gosh, these are awesome! Everyone at my house likes different kinds of candy bars, but we are all crazy about these. So good, and I don't choke on peanuts (like I do with regular Snickers). Sooooooo goooood!!!!!
Reply
1-04-2011 @7:45PM Bob said... Buy 1 and if you like it, buy more. If you don't, don't...Who cares?
Reply