Photo: Elizabeth Hait, AOL
Starbucks recently launched their new flavor for the fall season, Toffee Mocha, and we couldn't wait to try it. We love the fall for many reasons, and one of those includes getting our hands on the popular Pumpkin Spice Latte, so we were interested to see how this flavor would stack up against it.
We ordered the coffee both hot and cold (no whipped cream on either) and shared them among the Slashfood and KitchenDaily team members for a taste test.
The nutritional information isn't available online yet, but we're betting these drinks should be considered more of a "treat" than an everyday item, considering they taste like dessert.
Starbucks Toffee Mocha (Hot)
Grade: C
Our testers said: "Very sweet and not a very good toffee flavor to me. It tastes more like the regular mocha coffee that they already have." "I wouldn't mind a stronger hint of toffee. Leaves a very filmy taste in my mouth, though, which I don't like. It's a little bit too thick -- I don't like my coffee (or even my lattes) to be as thick as hot chocolate." "All I really taste is sugar. Maybe a little caramelized, but mostly just overwhelmingly sweet."
Starbucks Toffee Mocha (Cold)
Grade: B
Our testers said: "Was able to taste the toffee flavor in this one more and it was slightly bitter -- in a good way, I hate drinks that are too sweet. It also had a nice aroma." "I can taste the toffee more in the cold drink. But I don't really think I can taste much coffee. Still tastes like chocolate milk." "I'd rather just have some ice cream or a milk shake."
Fast Food Reviews
McDonald's Deluxe Angus Wrap
Grade: C-
Nutritional Info: 25 grams fat, 410 calories
What's in it: Angus beef, tomato, American cheese, pickles, lettuce and red onions.
Our testers said: "I wasn't sure how I would feel about eating my burger in a wrap, but turns out it wasn't so bad. However, when looking at the calories and fat compared to the actual burger, I might as well go for the full-fat option." "When I think of a 'snack,' I think of something less heavy and something that will boost my energy level. After eating this, I just wanted to take a nap." "My favorite part about this wrap was the crunchy pickles."
Bacon & Cheese Angus Wrap
Grade: F
Nutritional Info: 21 grams fat, 390 calories
What's in it: Angus beef, bacon, American cheese, pickles and red onions
Our testers said: "The ketchup mixed with the fake, stringy bacon produced a pungent taste in my mouth -- close to drinking tomato juice while eating a dry beef burger with waxy cheese -- it's not a good combination." "This wrap left me with no words -- it was that bad."
Mushroom & Swiss Angus Wrap
Grade: F
Nutritional Info: 26 grams fat, 430 calories
What's in it: Angus beef, mushrooms and Swiss cheese
Our testers said: "If there was a grade letter lower than F, this wrap would have received it." "This is a complete mess in my mouth -- the mushrooms tasted like they came right out of a can (with a metal aftertaste)." "I would much rather eat any one of those Taco Bell Cantina Tacos than ever eat this wrap ever again."
Taco Bell Cantina Taco - Chicken
Grade: B+
Nutritional Info: 2.5 grams fat, 170 calories
What's in it: "Southwest" chicken, onions, lime, cilantro (wrapped up in corn tortillas)
Our testers said: "This taco is easily better than any other item on their menu. The moist chicken had just the right amount of spice and the corn tortilla's were still warm, not gummy. If we had just one request, it would be to add more sauce or a spicy salsa."
Cantina Taco - Steak
Grade: D
Nutritional Info: 2.5 grams fat, 160 calories
What's in it: Onions, lime, beef, cilantro (wrapped up in corn tortillas)
Our testers said: "The steak and wrap were both dry -- when we tasted the beef alone, it was extremely chewy and lacked the simple basics like salt and pepper. It wasn't worth more than two bites."
Cantina Taco - Carnitas
Grade: F
Nutritional Info: 7 grams fat, 200 calories
What's in it: Onions, lime, shredded pork, cilantro (wrapped up in corn tortillas)
Our testers said: "Never has food looked so completely different in real life than in the advertised photograph. A pile of mush and odd flavors, this mixture of sweet pork and onions never came together. To be brutally honest, when opened up, this taco looked like cat food -- and not chunky style. We couldn't get through more than one bite."
KFC Original Doublicious
Grade: C+
Nutritional Info (small): 23 grams fat, 470 calories
Our testers said: "This is a much better combo -- the saltiness of the fried chicken balances out the sweet bread." "I'd much rather have the sandwich with the Colonel's Sauce rather than the honey mustard BBQ." "While the bun itself does not taste good, it is soft and fresh -- like it just came out of the oven, which is surprising for a fast-food establishment."
KFC Grilled Doublicious
Grade: D
Nutritional Info: 11 grams fat, 360 calories
Our testers said: "If you blindfolded me and didn't tell me what I was eating, I would have said this was a hot dog." "The combination of the honey mustard and the sweet Hawaiian bun was overwhelming, way too sweet." "I couldn't tell whether I was tasting the cheese or the sauce." "I'd much rather splurge on the calories and fat and eat the fried version."
Friendly's Grilled Cheese BurgerMelt
Grade: B+
Nutritional Info: 1500 calories, 97 grams fat, 2090 mgs sodium
Our testers said: The grilled cheese "buns" were buttery, oozing with just the right amount of cheese and just the right amount of greasiness. True, the burger could have been more plump and juicy but it was the right amount of beef to balance out the two grilled cheese sandwiches. The only thing we'd do differently is skip the lettuce. Watery, shredded lettuce did not pair well with the grilled cheese.
KFC's Double Down Sandwich
Grade: B
Nutritional Info: 540 calories, 32 grams fat,1380 mgs sodium
This sandwich isn't for the faint of heart. The sodium intake alone will knock you off your feet: Our testers determined the salty culprit seemed to be the breading on the chicken, though it was pleasingly crispy and the meat itself was quite moist. The bacon was legit -- it didn't have the usual weirdly chewy, artificial bacon-bit taste -- but it was essentially lost, both physically and flavor-wise (along with the cheese), between the two behemoth chicken filets. And there was a lot of discussion around whether the cheese was really a cheese spread, or if it had just melded with the special sauce.
Wendy's Spicy Chicken Caesar Salad
Grade: --
Nutritional Info: 49 grams fat, 740 calories
What's in it: Romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, shaved Asiago cheese, French bread croutons, Wendy's spicy chicken with a lemon garlic Caesar dressing.
Our testers said: We can't officially give this salad a grade because Wendy's forgot to put the salad dressing in our bag. However, we can say that the garlic croutons with sea salt, black pepper and garlic were absolutely delicious. And with Wendy's classic spicy chicken filet on top, we believe this salad has potential. We look forward to going back and trying this one again (with the dressing this time).
Wendy's BLT Cobb Salad
Grade: B
Nutritional Info: 47 grams fat, 670 calories
What's in it: Spring salad greens, two strips of Applewood Smoked Bacon, tomatoes, blue cheese, chopped egg, warm grilled chicken with a creamy avocado ranch dressing.
Our testers said: "Of course I'm going to like this one, it's full of fat and calories!" "The bacon was surprisingly good -- didn't have that chemical aftertaste most fast-food establishments can't avoid." "The combination of the chopped eggs, chicken and blue cheese went perfectly with a really light ranch dressing (which is hard to come by)."
Wendy's Baja Salad
Grade: D
Nutritional Info: 47 grams fat, 740 calories
What's in it: Spring salad greens, cheddar and pepper-jack cheeses, guacamole, Pico de Gallo, tortilla strips, Wendy's chili with a creamy red jalapeno dressing.
Our testers said: "Some people really like Wendy's chili, I don't, therefore this salad just didn't do it for me." "I found that the chili watered down the greens, which got lost underneath a heap of beef and avocado." "The only thing I liked about this salad was the refreshing Pico de Gallo, which there wasn't enough of."
Wendy's Apple Pecan Chicken Salad
Grade: C
Nutritional Info: 27 grams fat, 580 calories
What's in it: Spring salad greens, blue cheese, Granny Smith and sweet red apples, roasted pecans, dried cranberries, warm grilled chicken with a pomegranate vinaigrette dressing.
Our testers said: "I really wanted to like this salad, but it just didn't come together for me." "The combination of apples, cranberries AND pomegranate was overwhelming -- the salad was too sweet and the chicken got lost." "I would have loved this with just the apples, chicken, blue cheese and a simple vinaigrette."


Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight
Oldest Water on Earth Found Deep Underground
2013 Billboard Music Awards: All the Winners!
Selena Gomez Leaving Justin Bieber's House: Booty Call Rumors Swirl
Walmart Workers Pessimistic About The Company's Future
South American 'Crazy' Ants Are a Threat in Southern US














9-09-2010 @6:09PM Andi said... Yeah, my Starbucks barista told me that when she tried it there didn't seem to be enough toffee flavor. I might try it but I think only if I can get her to be a little bit more generous with the syrup first.
And yeah....don't ask about the nutritional info especially if you didn't ask for skim milk and added the whipped cream. Believe me, you don't wanna know!
Reply
9-10-2010 @12:40AM Vibs said... How many calories are in a tall?
9-11-2010 @11:49PM Donna said... Starbucks has messed up their drinks with whatever their new recipe is. The green tea frappacino is ruined ... a blah taste, not the same dark green color, no longer thick & creamy, and has some sort of a white stripe running thru it. Ugh. Gag. Haven't been there since this horrible change began.
Reply
9-11-2010 @9:05PM Scp said... I agree. Starbuck's has the worst tasting coffee ever. I wouldn't mind paying the price if the taste was decent. Give me Dunkin Donuts coffee anyday over Starbuck's.
Reply
9-11-2010 @9:42PM Jordin said... My cousin and I get Starbucks all the time and the filmy aftertaste is our favorite part.
Reply
9-11-2010 @10:01PM Lorna said... Mike, why are you belittling everyone so harshly? It's Starbucks we're talking about, not a nuclear missle site. Calm down and have a cup of decaf.
Reply
9-13-2010 @8:17PM robert` said... some of the spicy coffee taste like a smelly armpit
Reply
9-11-2010 @11:28PM Dennis Butler said... I think Starbucks coffee always tastes terrible with an aftertaste. I don't mind strong coffee, but Starbucks is also bitter...... and that causes the aftertaste. Their advertising makes their popularity - certainly not the quality of the product.
Reply
9-12-2010 @2:13AM Mz.Williams said... I know exactly what you mean about the after taste-definitely not my favorite part! However I think most coffees have some what of a nasty after taste. And I'm not quite a big fan of coffee I do enjoy their seasonal pumpkin spice frapp. My ultimate favorite is the passion fruit tea which is half the price of a coffee. Yep that's right, I go to a coffee joint for the tea :)
9-12-2010 @12:16AM Lena said... I LOVE Starbucks, They have the best coffee and they do everything right. No comparison to Dunkin Donuts w ishatsoever. The Venti Misto is the best tasting and the best value, a delicious cup of coffee for a true coffee lover.
Reply
9-12-2010 @1:20AM RUSS said... my opinion of starbucks...SCHTINX
Reply
9-12-2010 @1:40AM Michele said... Hey, that's the beauty of living in our country, we can drink any flavor coffee, from anywhere we like, so don't bash Starbucks, if you don't like it, go elsewhere, if you like Dunkin Donuts, fine and dandy. Why, do people always have to bash things on blogs? why? : /
Reply
9-12-2010 @2:05AM Carol said... We don't "bash" things, we give our opinions on what we feel whether you want to hear them or not. That is the beauty of freedom of speech. Give us a soap box or a forum and we will rant or rave for days and days. When you express your opinion, you have to be prepared for someone out there who doesn't share your point of view. (shrug) just sayin'
9-12-2010 @2:08AM Carol said... I was not impressed. Frankly, I haven't been impressed with Starbucks
for the last few years. The best coffee drink I had from them was a
Caramel Brulee Latte last year and they took it off the menu. Said it
was seasonal. I stopped back in last week to see when it was going
back on the menu and they said it's not. Said to try the Toffee one.
As I said, I am not impressed. Will not be back. Switching over to
Caribou Coffee. Theirs doesn't have that bitter, burnt taste. It's
very tasty.
Reply
9-13-2010 @10:25AM cathy said... In my town, once Stabucks went over $4.00 for my grande vanilla latte ($4.30) I said that's it. I felt the product didn't warrant the price. I always thought they should have a frequent buyer card but I guess they are too busy pushing coffee pots, mugs, games, cd's and that expensive instant coffee. I thought I would die without my Starbucks but I switched to Duncan donuts for $1.73 and it is great. http:newsy1.wordpress.com
Reply