Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


'Top Chef Vegas' -- It Ain't Over 'Till the Pregnant Lady Complains

top chef finalists

Photo: Bravo

It's only been two weeks since the last episode of "Top Chef," but thanks to the wonder of Bravo editing, it seems like it's been a lifetime. It's not just that the dry grime of the Vegas strip has been traded for the misty lushness of California wine country -- it's everything. The seasons have changed. Hairstyles have been altered -- or in Kevin's case, have gone completely untended. Padma is now buxom with child. For all we know, Michael has run out and gotten even more lame tattoos.

This can only mean one thing: We have entered the first part of the "Top Chef" finale -- now with 80 percent more pregnant pauses, concerned looks and furrowed brows! Certainly, the stakes are high enough without Padma, Tom and Gail being overly reverent and ominous, but still, they do the best they can to help ratchet up the tension.

The occasion this time was a Napa Valley "Crush Party," which, contrary to the moniker, was not a celebration of the complex flavor profile of Orange Crush. Rather, it was an opportunity for affluent wine-country moguls to let down their hair and ostentatiously stomp on some grapes with their bare, pedicured feet, thus celebrating the harvest season while their underpaid grape-pickers toiled in a faraway field.


For such a festivity, our quartet of finalists was enlisted -- yet again -- to prepare, by themselves, mass quantities of uniformly perfect little hors d'oeuvres celebrating local ingredients for hundreds of people, five of whom would be deciding their fates. Anyone would crack under this kind of pressure, which makes it even more of a wonder that the four managed to stay, cool, calm and collected -- even the Brothers Voltaggio, who have been threatening to melt down into groin-punching brotherly hate for weeks now.

Instead, the closest we came to a confrontation was Michael thinking big-bro Bryan was muttering to him, when really, he was involved in a dialogue with his ingredients: "I'm talking to my squash," he said, followed by his now-patented, Elmer Fudd-esque staccato laugh.

If anything, the stress manifested itself in strange, new ways. Jen's self-loathing, so under control in recent weeks -- has she discovered some new meds, perhaps? -- started to rear its ugly head when Tom stopped by the kitchen and found her back to her discombobulated ways. It's not that she didn't bring her A-game -- her mushroom, goat cheese and radish appetizer was inspired, if, by Padma's standards, too salty -- but, perhaps fatally, she betrayed a case of the jitters at a time when radiating confidence seemed to be the name of the game.

Charitably, Tom chalked it up at first to the nervous energy Jen usually uses to her advantage. But when a wood fire burned itself out and she was forced to cook her locally sourced duck confit instead of on the grill, she couldn't manage to spin the compromise into a story. Even after the judges praised her use of the entire duck in the dish, she 'fessed up and revealed that she would've preferred the smoky flavor of her initial plan. Of all the talents Jen may have, a poker face is not among them.

Meanwhile, Kevin had no problem talking his way out of his tough, non-slow-cooked brisket. Served up on a bed of luscious-looking pumpkin polenta -- so light and airy, it seemed to be floating above the plate -- the meat was judged subpar. But, in an uncharacteristic B.S. moment from the usually honest-to-a-fault chef, he managed to spin it as a contrast in texture. When outside of the judges' backs, he admitted : "I know that you're going to say it wasn't tender, but I'm gonna say it was toothsome!" Well played, red-bearded one, well played.

That left the brothers -- mild-mannered Bryan and cocky-as-all-get-out Michael -- to continue playing out what we can only imagine is a lifetime of sibling rivalry. (Either that, or they're just very good at acting out the stereotype.) After Michael won a grape-based Quickfire challenge judged by his idol Michael Chiarello -- the two share an affinity for snotty arrogance, to judge by this summer's "Top Chef Masters" -- he spent the rest of the episode patting himself on the back for using fresh, local food in a new way (for him, at least).

But while Michael earned kudos for cleverly pairing his foie gras with pear and turnip soup, ultimately his unfocused egg-and-vegetable pistou left most underwhelmed. Which left Bryan -- steady, robotic Bryan -- to gain the evening's crown by committing the least-of-all-evils sin of underflavoring, while highlighting the local ingredients the best. His fig-glazed short ribs looked luscious, to be sure, but Gail's comment that they weren't as bold as they could've been made us hunger for Kevin's no-doubt tougher but more flavorful beef.

And as for the night's big loser, well, we could've called the outcome as soon as Jen waxed nostalgic on her mentor Eric Ripert, early in the episode. It's pretty much the kiss of death if, at this late point in the game, the editors give you ample screen time to talk about your backstory and influences. It can only mean one thing: You're going home. Sure enough, Jen's plates, good as they were, were dismissed as "scattered," and the stoic chef bid a farewell that was at first unsentimental, but soon had her -- and in turn, us -- choking back tears.

Filed Under: Television/Film, Chefs
Tags: top chef episode 13, top chef las vegas, top chef las vegas recap, top chef recap, top chef vegas

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 1)

domynoe

12-03-2009 @11:40AM domynoe said... I was both disappointed and not surprised with the decision: by all the comments they aired, Michael should have gone home (and I really would not have missed him), but I pretty much suspected they wouldn't send him home to keep what little "drama" is left this season. I'm just glad Kevin is still in the running. At this point, not really thinking he'll win since all the focus is on the brothers, but at least he's in the finale. I've liked him all along, probably because of the lack of drama and his focus on the food more than anything. Besides, he's a local boy for us. ;)
Reply

TommyJr

12-03-2009 @11:55AM TommyJr said... I knew they would keep the brothers. An awful decision.
Reply

steve

12-04-2009 @12:14AM steve said... I was rooting for Jen all the way. But I knew they would never let one of the brothers go... sounds like the influence of the producers to me. It seemed like they were praising Jen's dishes, but then were grasping for excuses to get rid of her and keep Michael.
Reply

GL

12-03-2009 @12:51PM GL said... I was rooting for Jen and I find Michael to be as bitter at anyone else's success as he is cocky of his own talent.

That said, I don't think it was a bad decision on the judges' part to keep him over Jen. It seemed close between all three of the non-winners and, not having eaten the food, I can't say Jen was jobbed here. Particularly when we know they try to edit in such a way as to make viewers unsure of who might really be going home.
Reply

ivailo

12-03-2009 @2:09PM ivailo said... seems that with the moments from the next episode they gave away who would be the final top chef; padma was looking straight and kevin was the one in front.
Reply

domynoe

12-03-2009 @3:23PM domynoe said... Now that would ROCK (like I said, he's a local boy and been my fave since about the beginning), but I also doubt they would give it away like that—they never have in the past. If it comes down to the two brothers, I would say Bryan as he's been the most on top of things. Could you imagine it if Michael won? I can just see him not letting Bryan live down being "second best" when, at this stage, it comes down to the most minute of things.
Reply

domynoe

12-03-2009 @3:28PM domynoe said... GL

The brothers have bothered me since the beginning, more because they remind me of my own (finally not teenagers but still doing the teenager crap) girls, but Michael has bothered me more than Bryan. And I think you hit it on the head as to why. He's always denigrating other contestants' food. It's been said repeatedly, simple isn't bad if it's done well. Maybe he's why Tom said that remark to Kevin about others wondering why he would get complements on such a simple concept.
Reply

Eric Tsuei

12-03-2009 @4:34PM Eric Tsuei said... i haven't been keeping up but GL and bryan ftw!
Reply

Cs

12-04-2009 @12:45AM Cs said... Kevin gets my vote! He just shows up and cooks, no drama.
Reply

Jim Kosmicki

12-04-2009 @3:57PM Jim Kosmicki said... the judges have been consistent, even the guest judges, in articles and blogs that it is THEIR decision, not the producers. If anything, I can see the producers being concerned about no female in the final. All four were strong competitors and would have easily won in some past seasons (yes, Ilan, I remain unconvinced of your win). Jen has not done well under intense pressure and it's very believable that she would be the one to make the biggest mistake that sends her home.
Reply

10 Comments / 1 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links