Photo: smcgee, Flickr
It got me to wondering how parents choose the right cake for that oh-so-special Kodak moment. If you have a kid named Madeline or Lady Baltimore, you can get away with serving an eponymous cake. The rest of us have to weigh taste with what will look best smeared on that beaming butter bean's face. Do you go small or big?
My friends chose to stick with tried and true recipes -- a white cake with raspberry filling, cupcakes and a cheesecake for the adults.
But I'm still curious, what would you choose?

Forbidden America: Cold War-Era Map Shows No-Go Zones For Soviet Tourists
Tenants: Stench of Death Makes St. Louis Complex 'Unlivable'
2013 Billboard Music Awards: All the Winners!
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
2013 Billboard Music Awards: Arrivals Photos From the Blue Carpet!
Ricardo Cerezo, Facing Eviction, Finds $4.85 Million Lottery Ticket
Forever 21 Worker Fired After She Tells Her Traumatic Story
Man Takes Dump In Background Of Instructional Workout Video
Chili's Waitress Fired Over Facebook Post Insulting 'Stupid Cops'
MIT's cheetah robot runs faster, more efficiently, can carry its own power supply (video)










2-20-2009 @7:36PM LaurenU said... My little brother's first bday cake was a series of small train cakes, each a different color. Plain white cake to minimize brown shmear...lots of fun colors for frosting, each car a different color. It was the best!
Reply
2-20-2009 @7:36PM Tracy said... I had no idea what to do for my first child's birthday and ended up making a cake in a large rectangular cake pan and cutting the number one into it before frosting. We all liked it so much that it became a family tradition. Each year each child gets a cake cut in the number of their birthday.That child is 19 now and still wants his number cake each year as do my other children. Not only does it make a happy memory, it's extremely easy and when a picture is taken of your child and their cake you know exactly which birthday the pictures are from.
Reply
2-20-2009 @9:14PM Barbara Carlsen said... We have a family tradition of making a small cake for the high chair tray and of course the oh so funny "let's dig in with both hands" moment. Usually pretty plain, but with icing. There is always that magic moment when the otherwise sugar deprived toddler has that realization of pure and happy sweet bliss. The grownups get a different cake and it's varied a lot over the years. That one is all for taste and never seems to make it into pictures!!
Reply
2-20-2009 @8:53PM HaterTot said... Battenberg. Or any spongey white cake wrapped in marzipan. The theory being that the child is 1 and doesn't care and/or most of it will end up on the child's face/floor therefore, I'm picking for me - and that's my favorite!
Reply
2-20-2009 @11:34PM tzurriz said... I made a cupcake cake, and just handed my girl one entire cupcake for herself.
the cake: http://flickr.com/photos/jfroebe/3107751386/in/set-72157611175157623/
the bliss: http://flickr.com/photos/jfroebe/3106873915/in/set-72157611175157623/
Reply
2-21-2009 @9:17PM RobS said... Our daughter just turned one. We have avoided giving her sweets (other than fruit) up until now,. I didn't think we should start now. So I made a savory corn bread (tomato basil) and frosted it with a cream cheese & fresh mozzarella spread. I tinted some of teh spread and piped it on just like decorating a sweet cake. She loved it.
Here's a picture of the "cake":
http://www.flickr.com/photos/robsindelar/3283595892/
We had a "real" cake for the adults.
Reply
2-21-2009 @10:37PM Nicole said... OK, that settles it. My first born will be named Lady Baltimore, boy OR girl!
Reply
2-27-2009 @4:01PM Jody said... My daughter Annaleise just turned 5 and I knew she would receive about a million Barbies (okay, only half a dozen). I made her a Barbie doll cake with a real Barbie in it (the cake was her dress). Of course, I used the Princess Anneliese Barbie. When I was done, it looked kind of like a pregnant Barbie but Annaleise loved it anyways.
Reply
2-27-2009 @4:22PM Jody said... Sorry, I see that the topic is 1st birthdays. For Annaleise I bought a chocolate cake with chocolate icing. For my son Brennen, I made the cake. I bought a pan where you pour the batter into different shaped pieces. You then put the pieces together to make a 3-car train. I decorated it with brightly coloured icing. He loved it and he was a mess but that was okay. Since then I have baked their birthday cakes. I ask what flavour they want but I try to surprise them otherwise.
Reply
7-03-2009 @8:43PM lyndsea said... My daughter turns one this September and I just found recipes on wholesomebabyfood.com. Many of them are sugar and egg free...perfect for those parents trying to keep baby on a healthy diet and not wanting that to get thrown off, although I doubt one cake is gonna do that. Anyhow, they actually seem pretty tasty so I think I'm going to try one out for my little one.
Reply