Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Everyone's a Critic...

David Fishman at a New York restaurant
Including 12-year-old David Fishman of New York City. It seems that on a recent night, when his parents were going to be a little late getting home, they told him that it would be okay for him to go out and get some takeout for dinner. Instead of hitting the local Middle Eastern as usual, he took himself down to Salumeria Rosi, which had opened just a few days before.

Despite a crush of diners and reservations, the restaurant made room for him and he settled in for dinner. Fishman is something of a foodie and aspires to be a restaurant critic and so brought a notebook along with him so that he could record his impressions of the solo meal. The chef/owner came out to greet him and sent him home with some hazelspread as a treat for later. Later, his mom stopped by to pick him up.

I don't think I would have been aware or confident enough at 12 to take myself to any restaurant beyond a local sandwich shop or the food court at the mall. How about the rest of you?

[via the New York Times]

Source

Filed Under: Cooking With Kids, Raves & Reviews
Tags: David Fishman, DavidFishman, New York Times, NewYorkTimes, pre-teen food critic, Pre-teenFoodCritic, Salumeria Rosi, SalumeriaRosi

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 1)

Megan

11-18-2008 @1:39PM Megan said... A 12 year old dining alone is big news ? The NY Times must be having a slow day.

Also, if he's going to be a food critic, he's got to learn the basic rules: Be anonymous. Don't take notes at the table. Both of those ensure you'll get a picture of what the average customers gets at that restaurant.
Reply

Unknown

11-18-2008 @1:46PM Unknown said... Thank you Megan. And, yes at 12 I would have been confident enough to take myself somewhere beyond a sandwich shop (thanks to parents who never acknowledged age as anything more than a number).
Reply

Eric Howe

11-18-2008 @3:08PM Eric Howe said... There's actually a movement for this sort of thing: Free Range Kids.

http://freerangekids.wordpress.com/

Reply

KF

11-18-2008 @2:57PM KF said... My parents traveled frequently in my youth, and as one of four children, I was used to going out to dine once in while, sans parents. We certainly didn't make a production out of it, or try to stand out in any way, but we felt very grown up and always dressed for dinner. Our ages ranged from 8 to 15 at the time. On one of our more memorable dinners out, we went to a hotel which was, by our standards then "fancy." When we were eating, a girl came around with a bread board and offered us bread. When we grew up, there was NEVER a meal without a bread basket on the table, and we liked bakery bread. So, when we were each given a slice with a pair of tongs, and she went ahead to the next table, my 8 year other brother was offended. He said "Miss? Leave that bread here." She said "Pardon?" My brother tapped the table and said "The bread stays right here." She was so startled she just set it down and left it with him. He turned to us and said "What kind of a place is this, anyway? No bread basket is nuts." (Actually, I agreed with him then, and still do).
Reply

Fred

11-18-2008 @3:32PM Fred said... As a young man growing up in Chester County, PA, my culinary opportunities were limited to a lack of transportation. But, I was never allowed to order from a "children's menu", I was always challenged to try something new. When West Chester had their first Restaurant Festival, I was the one that insisted that we go, and that we try something from every booth. Eating out alone would have been no big shocker.
Reply

Anonymous

12-09-2008 @6:01PM Anonymous said... This kid is in my grade (yes I am also 12). He was like a celebrity, but he was kind of embaressed about being a food critic when he was 12 I guess, because no one knew anything about this until the article came out.
Reply

6 Comments / 1 Pages
Advertisement

Follow Us

Most Popular Stories

  • The Takedown Hits Austin During SXSW - Bacon Style

    The Takedown Hits Austin During SXSW - Bacon StyleRead More

  • Kitchen Gadgets that Remove the Guesswork

    Kitchen Gadgets that Remove the GuessworkRead More

  • Happy Birthday - What Can I Get You Folks?

    Happy Birthday - What Can I Get You Folks?Read More

Drool Over This ...

The Editors

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links