
Last Friday we took the day off from installing the steam pipes for our new brewery boiler, to bottle our first hard cider. This is the first new product to be released since I joined the team, and I had a lot of input towards its design. I have had some experience in the past creating hard ciders, both as a home brewer and wine maker, as well as commercially. Right after Mike and I shook hands to form our partnership late last November, I set off to Cornell University's Agricultural Experimental Station in Geneva, NY to take a week of workshops, primarily on advanced hard cider development and production techniques. The new information I picked up helped fine tune this cider into a great product over the past year.
We started with several different batches of sweet apple cider, fresh pressed from locally grown apples. Each batch had a different blend of apples and was fermented at cool temperatures using different yeasts. After the primary fermentation, the cider was taken off the lees (old, spent, dead and dormant yeast that settles to the bottom of the fermenting tank.) Then put into new tanks to age slowly for months and months, all at cool temperatures in our wine cellar. The cool temperature and slow, slow, slow, fermentation ensure that there will be lots of fresh apple flavor in the finished cider; as well as the tones and notes from the fermentation. Since each batch was made from different apples, and different yeasts; they had a completely different character from each other.
One of the craft secrets to creating a great hard cider is long and slow aging; and this we had done. The other is blending the cider. If you just make one, huge, batch of hard cider using all your apples, it tends to taste flat and one dimensional after fermentation. But if you make several smaller batches, with different apples in each, and later blend them carefully together; you get a final cider that is greater than the sum of its parts. Really great ciders save back some of the final blend to age even longer, and this is added to the blend the following year/s to bring in even greater complexity.
Next we took the blended hard cider and put it into a large fermenting tank to further age on oak. This additional maturation marries the blend of ciders, and the oak brings in a mild woodiness that pairs very well with the crisp, fresh apple taste. Now that the cider is almost a year old, it's just hitting its stride in both mature complexity, and fresh liveliness, with a final abv. of 7%.
We called our hard cider "Back Porch Maine Cider" as reminiscent of the feeling you get in late summer/early fall up here in Maine when you sit out on your back porch, looking out over the rolling hills, fields, woods, and streams below. Rachael, Mike and Joan's daughter-in-law, is our resident artist. She has an art gallery in our winery where we sell her drawings, paintings, and crafts. She also designs our wine labels, with a new painting gracing each one; and now our hard cider. She perfectly caught the feeling of Back Porch with an eye-catching painting that perfectly describes the stimulating, but relaxing feeling we were looking for.
Hard ciders really benefit from just a touch of carbonation, what the Italians call frizzante. Too much and you have a difficult time picking out the fine apple notes in the cider. Not enough and the cider lies flat and lifeless on your tongue. When you have the carbonation just right, the tiny little bubbles fizz in your mouth, tickling your tongue, and enlivening the cider; allowing you to discern all the fine flavors and aromas from the fermented apples.
To do this we put half of the batch of cider in a special tank in our cold room, saving the rest for later, and chilled it down to just above freezing. Then over the course of several weeks we slowly put it under gently increasing, but always mild, pressure with CO2. The long, cold, slow, light pressurization makes the CO2 dissolve fully into the cider, carbonating it, but lightly; so that you get tiny bubbles. Faster carbonation at warmer temps will give you big bubbles. It's easier and less time consuming, but we are willing to take the time; and do. It leads to a much finer end result.
During the whole cider-making process we only filtered the cider just enough after the primary fermentation to remove yeast sediment, but not enough to strip out any flavor. After that we left it alone, so it has a slight haze to it, significant because this means that it is packed with flavor.
We bottled the Back Porch it in crystal clear, 750 ml. sparkling wine bottles, with crown caps; the same style caps used for beer bottles. crown caps seal very well, you don't have the infection problems you get with corks, they are easier to remove than corks, and most crown caps have an anti-oxidation layer in the caps which not only prevents oxidation from gases passing through the seal, but remove any oxygen that may have been introduced during bottling. Hard cider is very prone to oxidation, and it can ruin a fine cider.
During the labeling an filling process the bottles are labeled first, then chilled down to the same temperature as the hard cider for 24 hours. This helps prevent wine or cider from erupting from a warm bottle before you have a chance to get the cork in or cap on. We finally got a new, pneumatic corker/capper for sparkling wines and beers a few weeks ago, so the process was a breeze compared to when we last bottled our sparkling apricot wine, Fancy That. Then we covered the cap and neck of the bottles with gold foil. We are still covering and twisting the foil on the bottles by hand, but Mike promised our next purchase will be an automatic foiling machine. My ice cold, and first numb; then sore and aching hands, can't wait.
Bottling our back Porch Hard Cider
Diary of a Distiller: Chapter 22 - An apple (cider) a day, keeps the Doctor away - Bottling Hard Cider(click thumbnails to view gallery)
After the cider bottling we got back to the last of the pipe installation. We attached all the connections of smaller steam in and condensate out lines, with steam traps, valves, etc. Then we spent half a day leveling out the full run of the pipe so that there was a slight down pitch from the far end, going back to the boiler. there are two reasons for this. Hot steam wants to rise, it is pumped uphill to the farthest point, with the steam being taken off of the top side of the 3" pipe here and there along the way, to be used for various equipment.
Construction
Diary of a Distiller: Chapter 22 - An apple (cider) a day, keeps the Doctor away - Construction(click thumbnails to view gallery)
The condensed and cooler steam is returned through the side of the large pipe as hot water and trickles downhill back to the boiler, where it is heated to steam again. Besides the gravity pulling the water back to the boiler, the steam flowing along the top of the pipe actually causes currents that force the hot water on the bottom of the pipe to flow in the opposite direction. So you get a two way flow within one pipe. Steam along the top going uphill, and hot water on the bottom going downhill. Thermo and fluid-dynamics, are weird, but great stuff.
We finished as much of the work as we could and the next step is for the steam boiler guy to come and inspect our work, assemble and install the boiler; make all the final connections, and test the system. Hopefully that will be next week.
Then we went back to work in the brewery to finish the piping for the cooling system for the brew kettle, chilling plate, fermenters, etc. The bulk of that will have to wait for next week as well. Have a great weekend folks and enjoy the beautiful Autumn foliage, I will!
Side Note: I was asked to give a few pointers on blending hard cider at home. So here's what first comes to mind.
Here are some professional tips to make a great hard cider.
First you need to make several batches of cider. Different apples in each batch.
Also try using different yeasts. Hard cider yeasts, different wine yeasts with various flavor profiles, etc.
After the batches have slowly fermented for a few weeks at cool temps, preferably in the low to mid-range for the specific yeasts. Try blending small batches with various amounts of each of the ciders. Focus on the strong and weak points of the batches. Play around. Wing it. See what develops.
One thing to remember is that hard cider oxidizes very easily. When making hard cider at home or at the winery, I have a tank of CO2, food grade, and top off the fermenter with the gas to flush out any air/oxygen. Remember with cider, and any wine or beer, once it is fermented, air/oxygen is not your friend. Especially with hard cider.
I use the CO2 tank to carbonate and keg my home ciders and beers in old Cornelius kegs, ie. soda syrup kegs. They are easier to sanitize and use than a zillion bottles, and they hold five gallons, a perfect home batch for beer or cider.
Also you can try adding other things to your blend. It isn't unusual, or wrong, in the science of blending hard cider, to add a little apple concentrate, or other fruit juice concentrates, or sweeteners like agave syrup or maple syrup, in very small amounts. 1-5%, to bring out sweetness, flavors, and aromas that you might otherwise miss. Before adding any sweetener you should kill off the live yeast with Camden tablets or other methods available to home winemakers and brewers. Then the yeast can't kick into gear again and ferment the sweetener.
When I was at that workshop at Cornell last winter on advanced cider production, we had a contest to see who could blend the best tasting cider. The one I created was considered the best. I used a blend of four hard ciders, one was real nasty and funky by itself, but when 7% was added to the three other nicer tasting, but innocuous ciders, it brought out all their good points and amplified them. While they covered up the negatives in the funky batch.
I also added 1% of sour cherry concentrate and 3% apple concentrate. This small amount of concentrate brought in barely noticeable flavors, but accentuated the ones already there, as well as the aromas. The apple concentrate also sweetened up the blend just a tiny bit, but it made all the difference.
Blending cider is both a science and an art. The only way to learn is to try out a bunch of stuff. Also if you get a batch that seems bad, or just doesn't work for you, save it. It may work really well another time in a different blend, or improve radically with age.
Good luck and let us know how it comes out.

'Undercover Boss': Top 4 Moments From Season 4 [VIDEO]
Las Vegas Court Officials Accused Of Covering Up Sex Assault [VIDEO]
Walmart vs. Costco: How Do They Really Compare?
Groomers Lose Dog, Claim Not Responsible
The Story Behind Shapewear: From Girdles to Spanx
'Grease' Cast: Where Are They Now?
Microsoft E3 2013 Xbox liveblog!
Baby Fox Asks for Help
Lost Dog Found 500 Miles Away
7 Myths of Long-Term Care













10-17-2008 @2:20PM Laura Thill said... This is my favorite entry in this series. I will never look at hard cider the same way again. Too bad I live in Missouri!
Reply
10-17-2008 @8:14PM chris said... Very interesting post. I am currently home fermenting some hard apple cider and planning to work on a new batch this week. What are your recommendations for experimenting with blending?
Reply
11-08-2008 @9:59PM Mark Luksich said... I have 30 gal of cider on the shelves in the basement. It is separated into 8 batches, with different yeasts, white, lite and dark brown sugars. The initial reading was 15 to 19, after a month at 61 degrees it was 0 or -1. This is truly going to be hard cider. My question is what do I age the cider in for the next year, or two or three? 3 gal Oak barrels, keep it in the plastic fermentation barrels? kill the yeast, add honey, maple syrup, apple concentrate? I have several hundred ltr beer bottles with wire tops, or several dozen half gallon mason jars.
Any advice is welcome. The juice was from a local apple orchard Richter's, on LI NY I had thought to make some of the cider sparkling - adding a bit of honey added just before bottleing.
Reply
11-12-2008 @5:31PM Rob said... Hey Jonathan, I'm just curious why you didn't age it on the lees?
Reply
11-12-2008 @6:15PM JMForester said... Rob- (My very good friend who runs a fine wine/liquor shop in NYC near the United Nations Building and is an expert on fine wines and spirits. We've worked at some of the same wine shops, but not at the same time.) I assume by aged on lees that you mean a secondary aging in the bottle with live yeast to naturally carbonate the cider.
The problem with this is that cider is a tricky critter. It oxidizes more rapidly and easily than just about any other fermented beverage, almost but not as easily as sake, and oxidation is a bad thing. It can bring in unwanted flavors and spoil a good beverage. Also you have to add food for the yeast, which means adding sugar in some form. In the case of cider this could mean actual sugar, fresh and unfermented apple juice, apple concentarte, etc. Adding any of these will change the flavor of the cider, and we wouldn't know if it was for the good or worse, until a few weeks later when the sealed bottles had developed their carbonation. In addition, the cider can pick up weird and nasty, musty flavors over time while sitting on the dead yeast bodies in the bottle.
So, we declined to carbonate naturally by a secondary carbonation in the bottle, and cold carbonated it under pressure. This we we know how it tastes, which we spent a lot of time working on to create, and we know it has less of a chance of the flavor changing in the bottle over time, in a negative way.
Reply
11-12-2008 @6:15PM JMForester said... Mark- your questions are interesting, I'll try to answer all of them.
First, I don't understand why you added sugar to any of your batches of hard cider. Sugar, when it ferments, adds its own flavors, and they aren't always good ones. By adding sugar before fermentation you change the way it will taste later, but with little or no control over it. Also you increase the amount of alcohol. Cider would naturally have an alcohol level of anywhere from 5.5%-7%. By adding the sugars you have now changed the product from a hard cider, to an apple wine.
Second, you say "The initial reading was 15 to 19, after a month at 61 degrees it was 0 or -1. " Which scale are you using? For brix or specific gravity? Was this before or after adding sugar. If after, what was the original specific gravity or brix?
Any which way, if the numbers are down to or less than 0, I am assuming that the fermentation is done. It sounds like you have a high alcohol apple wine there if the scale you are using shows the potential alcohol as 15-19%. Otherwise I assume it means the potential alcohol is 7.5-9.9%. depending which scale, is what the numbers mean.
Third, you ask "My question is what do I age the cider in for the next year, or two or three? 3 gal Oak barrels, keep it in the plastic fermentation barrels?"
For home cider making you want it to be in plastic for a very short primary fermentation of 1-2 weeks. Then get it off the lees and into a sanitized glass carboy for the longer, secondary fermentation/primary aging. Top off the carboys with CO2 in the headspace to prevent oxidation. After a few months you will have a good idea of what the cider is going to taste like. Then you can put in toasted barrels of you wish, but they are expensive. Or add toasted oak chips and test every week or two until you get the amount of wood you are looking for. Be conservative, it's easy to add more wood, but you can't take it out.
Fourth, "kill the yeast, add honey, maple syrup, apple concentrate?" Yes, do this after you get apx. the amount of wood flavor, or maybe a little less than you want. let it sit for another few weeks and test. then correct the flavor some more, add more wood, etc. Always to-p off the headspace with CO2 after each time you test it or mess around with it. Once you kill the yeast you have to be very careful about oxidation, so be gentle, and always top off the headspace with CO2.
fifth, making sparkling cider at home means adding sugars (priming) to get a natural fermentation in the bottle. for this use sugar. Use the amounts suggested in a good home brewing guide. if you add too much you will get exploding bottles.
Honey takes a long, long, time to ferment and varies in sugar levels and available nutrients. So you may, most probably will, have problems using it for priming. Also if you added honey prior to fermentation, or to live yeast at any point, expect it to take up to six months to fully ferment. It may never ferment and can cause a 'stuck' fermentation. Then a increase in temperature can cause it to kick in again, starting the fermentation over again, but not under your control. This is why making mead takes a long time, to make a good product.
Use the bottles you mention for still or sparkling cider. If they are in good shape, the rubber gaskets have only been used once, aren't all scratched up, and you can get them sparkling clean inside. If the gaskets are more than a year old or been used more than once you need to order new ones. Use the jars for still cider only, they aren't made for pressure and will explode. Make sure you sanitize everything extremely well.
Reply