Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


Serrated knife found baked into Subway sandwich

subway sandwich with baked in knifeRemember those old cartoons, in which one character would bake bolt cutters or a file into a cake, pie or loaf of bread, so that another character could bust out of the joint? I remember being highly entertained by those animated antics as a kid. However, as one New York man discovered recently, it's not nearly as amusing to discover something baked into your lunch in real life.

Bizarre objects found in food(click thumbnails to view gallery)

A ScrewA SyringeAn Oak LeafA Dead RatMouse Poop

On June 27th, John Agnesini of Astoria, NY was sitting down to a foot-long Subway sandwich when he noticed a few bites in that something just didn't taste right. Feeling something hard on the bottom of his bread, he turned over the sandwich to discover that a 7-inch serrated knife was baked into the bread on which the sandwich had been made. He was sick for nearly three hours after eating that small portion of the sandwich.

Subway refuses to comment on the incident and Agnesini is currently suing the chain for $1 million.

What would you do if you found a foreign object in your food?
Pull it out and keep on chowing down191 (2.9%)
Let the management know and ask for a refund2718 (40.9%)
Take a bunch of pictures and call a lawyer3732 (56.2%)


[via New York Post]

Source

Filed Under: Food News
Tags: baked in, BakedIn, new york post, NewYorkPost, serrated knife, SerratedKnife, subway sandwich, SubwaySandwich

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 5 of 7)

The Ween

7-17-2008 @5:30PM The Ween said... Those are the knives that they use to cut the sandwich in half with. It's actually longer than the half of sandwich he was eating. I'm sure he's glad it happened so he can sue for millions on an honest mistake that didn't hurt him. Only in America!
Reply

Nicole

7-17-2008 @5:31PM Nicole said... Seriously? I worked at Subway for a while and that's one of the knives they use to cut the sandwiches in half. They aren't serrated though, they're sharp - I cut myself a couple times regrettably). I don't know how the person making the sandwich could have shoved the knife INSIDE the sandwich and closed it up without noticing it though. I also don't see how this made the guy sick for hours afterward. THAT doesn't make sense. More than likely the knife was use to cut his sandwich so it wasn't contaminated with anything, just had whatever he had on his sandwich on it. I could understand if he cut his mouth on it, but sick? C'mon.
Reply

Nicole

7-17-2008 @5:59PM Nicole said... Seriously? I worked at Subway for a while and that's one of the knives they use to cut the sandwiches in half. They aren't serrated though, they're sharp - I cut myself a couple times regrettably). I don't know how the person making the sandwich could have shoved the knife INSIDE the sandwich and closed it up without noticing it though. I also don't see how this made the guy sick for hours afterward. THAT doesn't make sense. More than likely the knife was use to cut his sandwich so it wasn't contaminated with anything, just had whatever he had on his sandwich on it. I could understand if he cut his mouth on it, but sick? C'mon.
Reply

Kevin

7-17-2008 @5:37PM Kevin said... This is obviously false, and underscores what is wrong with this country today. Everyone is looking for the quick buck at whomever's expense is convenient at the moment. Let's go into a sandwich shop and claim a 7 inch knife is "baked" into a loaf of bread ("I'll claim it was a foot long to make more sense" - forgetting that they ABSOLUTELY cut ALL 12" sandwiches in half), then claim the two bites I took made me sick (from what, the THOUGHT of what MIGHT have happened?. Then I will sue for a million dollars for my conjured illness. We should all be able to sue people like this John Agnesini for screwing up our way of life. He should get jail time for attempting this.
Reply

Sharon

7-17-2008 @5:35PM Sharon said... I eat at Subway quite often,and have never had a knife in my sandwich. But if that did happen to me,
i would let the management know right away!

Reply

Action

7-17-2008 @5:37PM Action said... Sounds like someone is looking to get some easy money.
Reply

oblitr8

7-17-2008 @5:37PM oblitr8 said... littlesoda has a point it would have bin sticking out and did any one else notice that the knife had mayonnaise and stuff on it...if it was baked in and on the bottom it would be clean...wouldnt it???
Reply

jennet

7-17-2008 @5:46PM jennet said... please make your own sandwiches and bag it. you will save a bit most ot these people dont keep their hands clean.they wear gloves then take the money with the same gloves and move to the next person.food handlers need to be trained properly and tested.
Reply

ray

7-17-2008 @5:39PM ray said... don't you watch them make your subs? i mean... if you ask for peppers and they don't put them on, you notice it. so how don't you notice a knife when you clearly didn't order one?
Reply

Phyllis

7-17-2008 @5:40PM Phyllis said... I found the small blade that cuts tomatoes for a salad in the salad I was eating. I called the manager and he checked in the kitchen and verified that it was missing. Got my lunch free but I couldn't eat any more. I think I should own the restaurant now.
Reply

deb

7-17-2008 @5:52PM deb said... I used to manage a subway in Iowa and first of all it could not have been baked in the bread because it starts out frozen solid and is only about an inch around. I find it very hard to believe that it was baked into the bread there is no possible way it could have gotten into the dough before it was baked without really messing up the loaf this a case of someone putting it into their sandwich after they got it. It is always cut in half and sliced down the center it would have been impossible not to have seen it.This person is trying to make a quick million and I guarantee that it wont hold water in court.
Reply

BellaBlues777

7-17-2008 @5:55PM BellaBlues777 said... This article is a serious issue. If, indeed, a knife was found in the guy's sandwich, someone owes him a very good explanation and reimbursement. I am not, whatsoever, an advocate of frivolous suing; but where food is concerned, I consider it a crime of attempted murder or harm, or at the very least unnecessary carelessness, when a restaurant employee either tries to "take it out" on a customer by fiddling with the food, or is simply negligent. Sorry, but that should never be tolerated anywhere, anytime, nor under any circumstances.

Reply

ricardo

7-17-2008 @6:05PM ricardo said... O.J. did it.
Reply

lori barnett

7-17-2008 @6:12PM lori barnett said... i have worked for subway for 13 years......just don't see it happining....and this isn't the first, second or third time someone has TRIED to make this claim...knife 7"+ sandwich 12", cut in half= 6".... so he did not see this knife until he ate a few bites....bet he has a relative that works there!!!! and what made him sick?
Reply

wolfkitten65

7-17-2008 @6:14PM wolfkitten65 said... Well If it was a foot long sandwich. They ALLWAYS cut them in half. SO how could it be a 7 inch knife baked into the bread becasue the sandwich maker would have noticed this when they cut it in half.Who knows how it got in there. Maybe its a conspirosy with one of the workers there and this guy? Maybe they did leave the knife in there on purpose. ANd which half did he pull the knife out of< the other half looks almost gone, SO how did he get this knife out>I think Its a scam a lot of them out there like that, now .
Reply

Carol

7-17-2008 @6:16PM Carol said... The story is bogus!
Reply

Cheryl

7-17-2008 @6:21PM Cheryl said... Don't really believe this story. Just someone looking for a way to make money.
Reply

kathi parlier

7-17-2008 @6:23PM kathi parlier said... Subway allways cuts their foot longs in half AFTER making them, So why was a 7 inch knife found when it was cut in half. Whos to say this guy is not trying to scam Subway, maybe a knife was in there, maybe it was put there by an employee that knows this guy and they are in it togather to get a million.
And what half was this knife in, the other half looks almost gone so if it was in that half why did he eat most of it then find the knife. If it was in the half that is almost a whole one, then why did he not leave the bread open to show wherethe knife was found, and why would you start on your second half with some of the first half still left. Its just a thought, but this sounds like a scam
Reply

Caroline Partee

7-17-2008 @7:16PM Caroline Partee said... I actually had this happen in my boyfriends sandwich and when we called the subway we had picked up the sandwichs from all we were told was to bring the knife back and the manager said it was no big deal. It was extremely sharp and only reason he had not bit the knife was because after a bite he looked down and saw the tip of the knife.
Reply

glenn furry

7-17-2008 @7:10PM glenn furry said... I work in alot of subways and know how the bread is baked their is no way the knife was baked in the bread.when the sub was cut in half the knife was placed down beside the sub and when they roled the sub in paper the was over looked. so when the guy unroled his sub he had so see the knife. so now he lies to try to get money from a scam. they should lock the bum up and throw away the keys.
Reply

140 Comments / 7 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links