Spoilers! Spoilers!Last night's episode of Top Chef showed that there is a difference between being a great chef and being able to cook a meal in a home. Take Stephanie, for example. She can win challenges by the handful, but when asked to cook a meal for four, she overcooked a pot of couscous and tried to make a sauce out of peanut butter and tomatoes. In a way, it made me feel a bit good about my own cooking skills -- like, please, I cook dinner every night for 2-10 people and it (occasionally) looks a (a little bit) better than the turkey on rice that Mark made for the Quickfire.
For the Quickfire, contestants were asked to make a complete, healthy and tasty meal in 15 minutes. They received Uncle Ben's Ready Rice (90 seconds in the microwave and it's cooked) to assist them in their task. The show was cut to make it seem like the contestants who actually tasted their food did well, whereas those who didn't have time for a quick bite produced the lesser dishes. As he was tasting, guest judge Art Smith, personal chef to Oprah and James Beard award winner, kept referring to the dishes that he didn't like as "clever," which I thought was a pretty funny way to group them. Stephanie's seafood pancake, for example, was "clever" but heavy. Padma thought that Mark's miso-glazed turkey was chicken, and dry chicken at that. Top dishes included Dale's fried rice, Richard's tuna steak and tomatoes over rice, and Antonia's rice over salad, which won her immunity for the Elimination.
Keeping with the idea of creating easy and complete meals, the Elimination Challenge charged contestants with the task of creating a wholesome and delicious meal for a family of four with only $10. When I saw the contestants running around Whole Foods, checking prices on even the cheapest vegetables and trying to get out the door in 30 minutes, I couldn't help but laugh. For many of us, our lives look like that every day. I can't even count the times I find out at the last minute that I'm serving dinner for four instead of one, and have to dash out the supermarket at the last minute with only $10 cash in my pocket. And I know the point of the challenge was that it was supposed to imitate real life, but the chefs were so bewildered by the task that you could totally tell how few of them cook for their families at home. Stephanie even admitted that she grew up eating gourmet food, and that her family paid little attention to nutritional value when choosing meals.
In typical Top Chef fashion, Padma threw in a twist when the chefs entered the kitchen: She assigned each chef a soux chef -- a child from Art Smith's Common Threads program, which educates children about the importance of eating healthfully with their parents. The chefs responded to the news really well, and I was surprised about how happy they were to let the kids lend a hand. We learned earlier in the episode that Antonia has a young daughter, and she had some trouble keeping it together when she saw the kids walk in. In the end, however, she ended up winning for a stir-fry pasta dish with vegetables that the judges absolutely loved, and called "delicate enough for a child but flavorful enough for an adult." Nikki also did well with a one-pot chicken dish, accompanied by a cucumber and tomato salad. She said it was the first thing she learned to cook by herself. Andrew scored points for making fruit accessible in a savory dish.
The bottom three included Stephanie, Lisa and Mark. I found their dishes unappetizing as well, especially Stephanie's, a couscous with eggplants and zucchini, topped with peanut-butter chicken. I think we've all experimented with a dish like that, only to find it solidly mediocre -- I know that I have. Lisa was chastised because the edamame and black beans in her roasted chicken with edamame and black beans lacked flavor, though she said she thought they may have been over-seasoned. Mark made a vegetable curry with cinnamon rice and a cucumber salad, but it didn't include enough protein and was a bit too sweet for the judges tastes. Plus, he said the reason he thought he was in the bottom was because Tom Colicchio didn't like him, which made him just a bit too awkward to keep around and probably contributed to his ultimate elimination.
Some quick analysis: The bottom three for the Quickfire also happened to be the bottom three for Elimination, which means that Stephanie and Lisa had better step it up. The judges seemed particularly disappointed with Stephanie's dishes, given her success in past episodes. Antonia woke up determined and totally plowed through the day. I know that she's not many people's favorites, but I think she's a great cook and really fun to watch, so I'm still rooting for her. I see Andrew as someone who has really been coming into his own on the show lately, I definitely feel like I understand him more after learning that he lost a lot of weight and now prioritizes healthy cooking. He's growing on me, and I don't feel ready to see him go just yet. He and Nikki are to competitors who I thought I'd see leaving early, but are beginning to prove themselves. Alas, Richard still has the mad skills, and there's much work to be done before anyone surpasses him.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-01-2008 @ 10:17AM
Harlan said...
The criticism of Stephanie's peanut butter/tomatoes combination was totally unfounded. That combination is used to superb effect in W. African cooking, with groundnut stew. See, for example, this vegetarian Moosewood version which I've made many times: http://www.recipezaar.com/134225
This said, she may not have pulled it off very well, which deserves criticism. But the judges showed their Euro-centrism by being unaware of this totally traditional and totally delicious African flavor combination.
All-in-all, a disappointing episode. This show should be about top "chefs", not top "home cooks" or top "wedding caterers" (see previews for next week).
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 10:26AM
paulcole said...
Am I alone in thinking that there is no way that they stayed under $10 at Whole Foods?
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 10:30AM
jill said...
It is interesting that some chefs had difficulty planning a meal that is appealing to kids. Don't children ever show up at any of their restaurants? I Some of those dishes were pretty embarrassing.
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 10:36AM
Patrick said...
they appeared to (pulling off leaves of bok choy to get under the $10 mark...which seems like a complete waste of food in an episode centered around poor kids). that said, my first reaction was: 'whole foods?' I know they're a sponsor for the show, but no one dealing with money issues shops at whole foods. there are plenty of places to get relatively inexpensive fresh meats and vegetables...and by relatively inexpensive, I mean in direct relation to whole foods' ridiculous mark ups.
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 11:05AM
R. P. McMurphy said...
Just remember, it's a show....it's cut up to make things appear differently.
Also, it seems, after watching all of the seasons, that you usually are damned if you do, damned if you don't. It's really unpredictable when it comes to which direction you take as far as going "gourmet" or "down home cooking".
10$ is not SOOO hard to keep under (ok, it's a little at whole foods especially), you're only buying your main ingredients, so a protein a veggie, and a starch in most cases. 4 people isn't a lot of veggies and starches are usually cheap for 4 people. The rest of the ingredients are in the kitchen already.
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 11:36AM
Stormwater said...
Except for Padma. She's not like us. She's prettier and smarter than us :).
http://www.filterra.com/index.php/product/plants/
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 5:36PM
Shannon said...
That's why we call it the Whole Paycheck...
Reply
5-05-2008 @ 11:57PM
Patrick said...
I highly doubt it was $10 total, because there was a shot where they had 7 meals plated. So it was probably $20 total for 7 or 8 dishes, which comes out to $10 for a family of 4. Also, looking at the ingredient lists of the contestants, there is no way they could buy that many items because packaged goods easily cost $4 by themselves. Meats are $6+ per lb and you would have to buy 1-1.5 lbs for a family of four.
As for having to shop at Whole Foods, I wonder how many comments they didn't air about how little you can buy at Whole Foods!
Reply
5-06-2008 @ 3:34PM
Gail said...
I made the stir fry recipe last night, and it was excellent. I know that I was well under 10 dollars for a 4 person serving, although I didn't count the teriyaki sauce, which I already had in my pantry. I used chicken thighs instead of breasts, and had to use frozen edamane.
We decided a cup of edamane was a bit too much for our tastes, and would sub in more bokchoy, which at my local asian market was amazingly cheap - like 69 cents a pound.
Reply