Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


What is your favorite flavor of pie?

close up image of half an apple pie.Pie is probably one of America's favorite desserts. The question is what is America's favorite kind of pie?

Michael Park over at Epicurious.com gives us some answers. He revealed a pie poll from the makers of Mrs. Smiths, Schwans Consumer Brands North America. The poll asked participants to name their three favorite pies. Which one came in first, you ask? Well, it was apple of course! Turns out it was the overwhelming favorite.

I was personally surprised that Key lime pie was at the bottom of the list. But I guess with so many kinds of pie out there, it's a measure of the popularity of key lime pie that it made the list at all. So how about it? What's your favorite kind of pie?

Filed Under: On the Blogs, Lists
Tags: apple pie, ApplePie, dessert, epicurious.com, pies

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 2)

Ian

4-21-2008 @11:23AM Ian said... pumpkin, cheese, apple -- in that order.
Reply

Ian

4-21-2008 @11:25AM Ian said... erm, yeah, cheese cake has cake in the name, but I decided to count it as a pie for some reason...
Reply

kassie

4-21-2008 @11:28AM kassie said... strawberry rhubarb and mincemeat.
Reply

Mike

4-21-2008 @2:57PM Mike said... Hmm, after living in NZ for a year, I have to say I love a nice mince pie or even a Butter Chicken (indian) Pie.
Reply

texasannie

4-21-2008 @11:46AM texasannie said... Pumpkin, lemon, key lime. Apple pie is fine, but it's not even in my top five.
Reply

bethany

4-21-2008 @12:03PM bethany said... my dad makes a phenomenal chocolate pecan pie around the holidays... that has to be my favorite. Following would be coconut cream and peach.
Reply

Adam S

4-21-2008 @12:51PM Adam S said... Chocolate Banana Cream
Shepherd's
Chicken Pot
Blueberry

In that order
Reply

Julie

4-21-2008 @1:13PM Julie said... In order I would have to say; "Cherry, Blueberry and Peach. I would like to give an honorable mention to Coconut Cream and Lemon Meringue of which I also find quite tasty.
http://www.noshtalgia.blogspot.com/
Reply

KF

4-21-2008 @1:36PM KF said... For cream pies, it's a tie between coconut cream or banana cream (I'm partial to Marie Callendar's versions). For fruit, hot, it would be heated mixed berry pie alamode. For fruit, cold, it would be fresh glazed peach pie with unsweetened whipped cream.
Reply

izzy

4-21-2008 @2:20PM izzy said... Lemon meringue and key lime are my favorites, apple is definitely one of my least favorites.
Reply

cmtdrt

4-21-2008 @2:54PM cmtdrt said... Pecan.
Reply

ann lemons

4-21-2008 @5:12PM ann lemons said... Blackberry
Gooseberry
Rhubarb

And apple is way down there, although I've had some good ones. Peach makes no sense at all; peaches are too good to can and put in pies.
Reply

KF

4-21-2008 @8:05PM KF said... Ann #13, I'm with you for COOKED peach pie, but try FRESH glazed peach pie. Like with a fresh strawberry pie, the freshly ripe peaches are cut into halves and lightly glazed (very lightly -- try to avoid too much goop, and served open in a baked crust, with whipped cream. That is a sublime summer treat, without ruining the peach.
Reply

Jan

4-21-2008 @8:50PM Jan said... wiled Black berry, made from just picked black berries. Look out for the stickers, and that big bee that got me last summer.
Reply

Jane

4-21-2008 @10:35PM Jane said... I am a pie lover. I always like to cook pie by myself. Thanks to the cookbook "Pie", now with it I can cook many different pies. It features tried-and-true recipes for 300 delicious creations, all of them sweet, savory, and very highly recommended: http://dealstudio.com/searchdeals.php?deal_id=98476&ru=279
Reply

Rita

4-21-2008 @10:54PM Rita said... Rhubarb
Lemon Meringue
Pumpkin
Peach
Cherry
Reply

EF

4-21-2008 @11:31PM EF said... Pumpkin
Apple
Chocolate Cream
Peach
Cherry
Key Lime
....Okay, I think I need some pie.. like right now..
Reply

Bernie B

4-22-2008 @2:55AM Bernie B said... Blueberry (Fresh, not from frozen berries)
Pecan
Mincemeat (Grandma's recipe that uses Lard)
Reply

JB

4-22-2008 @6:48AM JB said... There's only two kinds of pie I like...Hot and Cold
Reply

bigkingken

4-22-2008 @9:26AM bigkingken said... Nobody has mentioned my two favorites. The first goes back to my childhood, something called Sugar Cream Pie. It must be an Indiana thing, but it consists of sugar, cream, eggs, and a sprinkle of nutmeg on top, all baked together. Best when served cold and mostly solid.

My second favorite pie I've only ever had once. It was called Ricotta Pie, and I got it from Mike's Pastries in Boston's North End. It was simply divine. I've tried recreating it, but have yet to find quite the right recipe.
Reply

23 Comments / 2 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links