Skip to main content
Skip to main content

The great banana panic continues

Dan Koeppel really, really likes bananas. A lot.

So much so, in fact, that he wrote a book about it: Banana: The Fate of the Fruit that Changed the World.

In an interview on Fresh Air, Koeppel explained that bananas are facing an epidemic that could, in a matter of decades, wipe out the fruit as we know it. For most of us, this would be a tragedy, considering that Americans eat more bananas per year than apples and oranges combined.

But what's killing them? Koeppel told host Terry Gross that the fruit is being struck by a fungus called Panama Disease, which is incurable and has been known to wipe out banana plantations in a few years. Unfortunately, the bananas that are falling susceptible to the disease are ones that were previously thought to be resistant. Oops.

The main reason that bananas are falling prey, Koeppel says, is because the cavendish bananas that are eaten in America, China, and Europe are essentially clones of one another. Each banana is genetically identical to the one next to it, so if a disease strikes one, it strikes them all.








So in order to combat this vulnerability, farmers are spraying their plantations with chemicals, and experimenting with genetic modification (GM) to develop more resistant strains of the fruit. For instance, they're crossing one banana with another, or using attributes from veggies like radishes, which have shown to be extremely resistant to diseases.

But what about organic bananas? Surely, they provide a safe alternative to regular cavendish bananas. Well, not according to Koeppel. He claims that there is not enough land worldwide to devote to growing organic bananas in order to make them a practical replacement for regular ones. In order to fight diseases, they must be grown at cooler temps and higher altitudes, and there are not enough locations hospitable to organic farming to make them a viable replacement for regular bananas.

The interview is worth listening to; Koeppel and Gross discuss the banana's history, the different types, and banana traits that differ from country to country. But enjoy that fruit with your cereal while you can - pretty soon, it may be extinct.

Source

Filed under: Farming, Business, Newspapers, Health & Medical, Ingredients, Books
Tags: cavendish, Fresh Air, fruit, Koeppel, NPR

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 1)

corey_harmon

2-24-2008 @5:48PM corey_harmon said... The cloning issue is the one that scares me with the recent FDA decision to clone beef. Disease will be a major issue.
Reply

snuffy

2-24-2008 @9:19PM snuffy said... At my university they are serving many banana-based dishes in the dining hall to raise awareness about this. I would definitely be interested in buying organic bananas since they are my favorite fruit. I assume they taste different (probably better) than the cavendish, right?
Reply

John Frost

2-24-2008 @9:20PM John Frost said... Cavendish Bananas are 'clones' of each other in the same way that one plant is a clone of another when you take a cutting of it and grow the cutting into a full plant. Banana trees have no seeds, so using a cutting is the only way to do it.

Do listen to the interview. I'd love that the result of this is that we get more varieties of Bananas in our local stores. The Cavendish is great for a snack, but it sounds like there are other varieties out there that are much tastier and better suited to cooking in dishes.
Reply

LinC

2-25-2008 @9:48PM LinC said... An "organic" banana is likely to be a Cavendish that's just grown in a different place. You need to go through hundreds of bananas to find a seed, which is why bananas are popagated from cuttings. We've lived with bananas so long that they've gotten used to us doing their reproduction for them.

Here's a thorough Popular Science magazine article (from 2005) on the subject:
http://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2005-06/can-fruit-be-saved

One interesting note -- this has happened before. In the early 20th century, the popular banana variety was the Big Mike. It had a similar population crash due to disease. You hear an echo of that in the children's song "Yes, We Have No Bananas."
Reply

fizil

8-26-2008 @10:45PM fizil said... Didn't this happen to all those irish bananas...i mean potatoes?
Reply

bob

4-07-2008 @10:30AM bob said... hiya
i would like to know what type of Banana is in thailand or is there none
as soon as someone sees this please email me back
as soon as
okay
xx
Reply

7 Comments / 1 Pages
Advertisement

Follow Us

Most Popular Stories

  • KFC Offers Edible Reward for Missing Colonel Sanders

    KFC Offers Edible Reward for Missing Colonel SandersRead More

  • Free Pancakes at IHOP on February 23

    Free Pancakes at IHOP on February 23Read More

  • 'Iron Chef America' - Duff, Meet Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman

    'Iron Chef America' - Duff, Meet Dr. Quinn, Medicine WomanRead More

Drool Over This ...

The Editors

Latest Flickr Feed


Cookbook Spotlight

Amazon.com
Mad Hungry: Feeding Men & Boys

Anyone whose looking to bang out delicious meals for hungry appetites should own this book.

Learn More
Sponsored Links