Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


What is your Ultimate Grilled Cheese? This is Mine.

sarah's ultimate grilled cheese sandwich
Given that April is National Grilled Cheese Sandwich Month, I couldn't let the month go by without making, eating, and posting about grilled cheese at least once!

Everyone has their favorite grilled cheese sandwich, whether it's a slice of Kraft American on Wonder White made at home, or some complex combination of fancy cheeses on fancy bread. People also have their favorite "accompaniments." My Ultimate Grilled Cheese is one I make at home: razor thin slices of sourdough bread filled with extra sharp cheddar cheese and thinly sliced tomatoes. I know tomato soup is a popular accessory to grilled cheese sandwiches, but I prefer just throwing fresh ones into the sandwich to make it easier. I have to cut the crusts off and eat them while I'm standing there over the chopping board, then cut the sandwich into long strips. When I eat them, I feel like I'm eating cheese-filled French fries.

Now, what's your Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich?

Filed Under: Raves & Reviews, Ingredients, How To, Methods
Tags: america, appetizers, cheese, comfort food, dinner, grains, grill, grilled cheese, grilled cheese sandwich, hors doeuvres, lunch, sandwich, sandwiches, tomato, tomatoes, vegetables, west coast

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 7)

abbe

4-16-2007 @12:14PM abbe said... i think ill eat yours!

Reply

MJ

4-16-2007 @12:45PM MJ said... This is missing something.......LOL
Reply

Jess

4-16-2007 @1:03PM Jess said... Can't go wrong with good ol' processed american cheese, dill pickle slices and just a bit of mayo on crustless white bread.
Reply

Thales

4-16-2007 @1:14PM Thales said... I take some whole grain bread, toast it half way, then put in some mild cheddar cheese and some very crispy bacon. Then lightly butter the outside of the sandwich and pop it back into the toaster oven for a few moments to melt the cheese and butter.
Reply

Stephanie

4-16-2007 @1:15PM Stephanie said... Whole wheat bread, one slice American cheese and one slice of muenster. Delicious and fat free, well maybe only delicious. :)
Reply

Foodie Bride

4-16-2007 @1:15PM Foodie Bride said... MMMmmm. Grilled cheese. Thick sliced ciabatta with mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, and a couple of basil leaves.
Reply

etrain

4-16-2007 @2:01PM etrain said... A local restaurant has a "Non-traditional grilled cheese" which I tried last night. Oatmeal bread, fresh vermont cheddar cheese, bacon, and extra-chunky peanut butter. YUM!
Reply

Chris Furniss

4-16-2007 @1:22PM Chris Furniss said... Oh god that looks fantastic.

(also, spelling counts!)
Reply

Brighella

4-16-2007 @1:30PM Brighella said... Onion Deli Rye Bread
Swiss Cheese
Bread and butter pickles
and the secret ingredient.....(drum roll)
Bever mustard Mmmmmmmm!

oh and you have to use real butter on the bread or it just doesnt come out quite right
Reply

sarah

4-16-2007 @1:32PM sarah said... fixed! thanks chris!
Reply

Random

4-16-2007 @2:27PM Random said... I'm addicted to the croque monsieur. But when I don't have ham or swiss, a good old sandwich composed of cheddar cheese (never ever American) between two slices of buttered wheat. And I constantly press down on the sandwich with a spatula while it's cooking.
Reply

Kassie

4-16-2007 @2:41PM Kassie said... White bread, buttered on both sides, velveeta, and grilled onions with a side of tomato soup.
Reply

Mijs

5-31-2007 @6:51PM Mijs said...
Real deli rye with seeds, buttered both sides. Toast both sides on flat top grill. When toasted apply your favorite cheddar, to both sides. Then add sliced brie to one side. Add capicola to the other side. Place sides together, and grill until molten.
Cut and serve.
Later Mijs
Reply

Renata

4-16-2007 @3:14PM Renata said... Feta, crisp bacon and avocado with optional tomato, on Woolworths seed bread (multigrain) in the good old wheat days; now on almond rice bread. Mmmmm, sweet & salty, creamy & crunchy - delicious! (Also great as pizza topping.)

As a backup plan, sharp cheddar and granny smith apple does the trick quite nicely. Add walnuts and dip in honey for fun.
Reply

themuttprincess

4-16-2007 @7:10PM themuttprincess said... My ultimate grilled cheese is made of:

Rye bread
Bacon
Fresh Roma Tomatoes
Muenster cheese
Cheddar cheese.

YUM!
Reply

stuart

4-16-2007 @4:07PM stuart said... that's quite a fine grilled cheese you've got there, extra points for presentation.

mmmm, grilled cheesy goodness

any grilled cheese lovers in So. Cal. should keep an eye out for info on the 2008 Grilled Cheese Invitational, featuring 3 categories of cheese grilling competition (this year's GCI happened in Feb and drew 60 contestants and about 500 grilled cheese fiends).

http://www.grilledcheeseinvitational.com/


Reply

Alex

4-16-2007 @4:13PM Alex said... Sourdough bread with what ever cheese I have and a piece of Ham. When in the pan, compress it with the side of the spatula or a plate and some cans. Makes everything that much better. Yum, now I want one.
Reply

Shad Genki

4-16-2007 @4:36PM Shad Genki said... Grilled ham and cheese on wheat.
Reply

alli

5-20-2007 @7:44PM alli said... whole wheat bread, 1 slice swiss 1 slice cheddar w/half an avocado. and ranch to dip.
Reply

Cory

4-16-2007 @7:59PM Cory said... fresh bread, 1 slice of muenster, one of cojack, thinly sliced tomato, grilled (or perhaps fried) in a bit of olive oil. perfection.
Reply

133 Comments / 7 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links