That is the least appetizing looking cake I may have ever seen. I almost don't want to read the book, either!

Reply

Agreed. That's a bad cake. I think if that showed up at a party, the birthday boy/girl would cry.

Reply

Oh, you should read the books. They don't get really good until the 3rd one. From there, they're totally addictive. As for the cake, I'll pass.

Reply

I would never eat that cake. But a birthday kid crying? I doubt it most people would love a cake like this, not to eat but more to look at. I don't see why someone would think to eat a cake shaped like a book in the first place. That is just stupid. No, no, no cakes like this one should be just looked at or shown off at a Harry Potter themed birthday party or like a 'Two weeks till the book comes out' celebration.

Reply

i LOVE the books and the movies.... the cake is iffy but i'd eat it if i had to!

Reply

Someone has a lot of free time on their hands, don't they?

Anywho, I think the cake is good-- for some weird cake competition where you decorate it and what not. It seems like a waste of time to eat it. But I highly doubt the kid would cry. Those little kids go crazy for Harry Potter. They'd love it. But no one over the age of 15 (at least no one normal) would be thrilled to have it at their party.

As for the book itself, I'm looking forward to it. They are really addicting (first, second, and fourth are bad, though).

Reply

I'm over 15, and I'd be ecstatic to have that for my birthday party! I'd be a bit sad to eat it since it's so cool though...

Reply

hey im thirteen, and im a harry potter junkie. the books are all amazing, especially the 3rd and 5th. i know adults over 45 that would love to have that cake at a birthday party. and to me, it looks appetizing. it must have taken a long time to make that, and i dont think any of the rest of you guys have the skills to draw a replica of a harry potter book, let alone draw a smiley face. and what's up with the criticism of the shape? all cakes are squares, at least the most common shape now a days is either a square or circle.

Reply

I agree with Jenni. I want to see an adult do that. You people who comment are mostly adults anyway, that have nothing better to do, execept to trash talk about children books. That is all I have to say.

P.S. I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!!! ;-)

Reply

wtf is wrong w/ you ppl?... 1st of all, like any of your lazy asses would even spend the time making a cake that took some time and creativity!... and then to say you wouldn't even eat it? -who tf are you?!... well, whoever you are, stay away from my party. as a fan, if someone made this cake for me for a party, i'd be thrilled! they obviously spent time on it and i think it's great. how dare you knock them.

Reply

Just wanted to let you know that there are adults out here that appreciate the work it took to make this cake and if it's chocolate I'll eat it too. I am in my 40's, I love Harry Potter. I have all the books and movies and will be at Barnes and Noble on June 20th to pick up my pre-ordered copy of the newest book dressed as Professor McGonagal. Kudo's to whomever took the time to make this wonderful cake.

Reply

That looks AMAZING! It has fantastic detail and the person(s) must have really taken their time with it. I'm above 15 and I LOVE the Harry Potter books; if a friend ever bought me a cake for my birthday shaped like the book I'd be thrilled. XD I want the top third(1/3)/fourth(1/4) of the cake!!

Reply

wow you guys are too hard on hp, these books are AMAZING and an 13-year-old made this cake for a "eat a book" day at her school so chill

Reply

Wow!! A thirteen-year old made that cake! That person is very talented and quite artistic. I hope the person who made the cake goes into the cake-decorating business because I would most certainly buy a cake from them!

Reply

It looks like one of those giant fuzzy books ;]
you should take a picture looking down on to the top of the cake. Just my opinion, but I think it might look at bit more appetizing that way. I can't wait till the book is released....I'll probably read it three times through without taking breaks :] Kudos to the cake baker. It looks wonderful.

Reply

i am only 12 yrs old going on thirteen soon and i think that might be THE MOST esquisite thing i've seen in my life. and yes kudos to whomever DID make that cake. and for the record i WOULD eat that cake. and even thought im not such a great fan with harry potter books, just by looking at that cake; i probaly WOULD read it. (i've read the 1st and 3rd book their not half bad but as another person commented those book types are just not for me) anyway i just wanted to say that and i also think the cake has high definition quality!-lol


P.S-all cakes or most cake are square shaped and circle shape as jenni commented so NY that just shows your stupidity-no offenese but its kind of true espically if it's coming from a 12 year old!-lol. sharpen up on ur shapes and sizes of things before you comment on them...:P

Reply

Knowing these comic books...the cake is probably vomit flavored and harry is sweat flavored,

Reply

i lik CHOCOLATE MILK!!!!


I LIK CHEEZ!!!

Reply

June 20th? Wow. I'm not going until July 20th.

Age 42 and a big Harry Potter fan. Love to read.

Reply

Wow... even I would have given up reading Harry Potter if I had started with the (meant for second-graders) first book... of course an adult cannot be pulled into that world. The 5th book deals with way more mature topics (death, romance, adulthood...namely how adults are not perfect) that makes it easier to be sucked in. Ugh. I find it so sad when I know someone is missing out. :(

I probably would eat the cake if it was lemon-y inside.

Reply