Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


The most anti-climactic pickle taste test ever

Vlasic picklesThe Boston Globe's food section got a bunch of people to taste test six brands of kosher dill pickles and give their opinion. The comments for Claussen range from "tastes like it came out of storage" to "an oyster in a pickle's body." And mind you, Claussen was the winner of the taste test.

The Globe also tested Vlasic, Mt. Olive, Boar's Head, Ba-Tampte, and Cains, and none of the brands blew the tasters away. Every single pickle tasted got a lot of negative comments, it's just that Claussen got the least amount of negative comments.

Personally, I like a lot of these pickles. I've never tasted Ba-Tampte, but the comment that it tasted like "gasoline" reminded me of one of my favorite Andy Griffith Show episodes, where Aunt Bee makes the pickles that no one likes. What do you buy when you want a dill pickle?

Filed Under: Raves & Reviews, Newspapers, Stores & Shopping, Lists
Tags: boar's head, cains, claussen, dill pickles, mt. olive, store bought pickles, stores-and-shopping, vlasic

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 1)

fumbducker

7-27-2006 @3:52PM fumbducker said... guss's pickles, made in new york, sold in nj whole foods (and when im in the city i go to the source)
Reply

Elysa

7-27-2006 @3:57PM Elysa said... The best grocery store bought pickles have to be Bubbe's pickles. They are from San Francisco and have no sugar and no preservatives. They are just pure dill flavor without overkill. Great!!
Reply

Rhea

7-27-2006 @4:17PM Rhea said... I saw that article. Pickles in jars are just not crunchy and flavorful like pickles you get at a deli. For good pickles, you have to find a deli and get 'em out of the barrel.
Reply

Andrew

7-27-2006 @4:33PM Andrew said... FWIW, I side with the article; Claussen's the best of th e bunch. I can't stand Vlasic.

Whole Foods Market sells some pickles that look promising, but I have yet to try them.
Reply

Jessica

7-27-2006 @7:06PM Jessica said... i'm a Vlasic girl

but you can't beat the huuuuuuuge barrels of dill pickles in random general stores, or on the NY streets.
Reply

Steph

7-27-2006 @7:23PM Steph said... Gotta be Tony Packo's Pickles!! http://www.tonypackos.com/history.html
A favorite of Jamie Farr's from M*A*S*H! Restaurant is in Toledo, Ohio' but pickles do travel! Enjoy! Sweet Hots are very tasty pickles with a kick, other varieties available too. Bet they would've garnered some positive comments from the survey!
Reply

Candi

7-28-2006 @10:01AM Candi said... I eat the Bah Tempte Half Sour pickles.. They are the best. It has to be the Half Sours though.. These are the ones that taste like the ones you get in all those Polish/Jewish delis in New York City.
Reply

ann

7-28-2006 @10:58AM ann said... i absolutely adore Nathan's Famous Dill Spears
oddly enough, I've yet to find them in a grocery in NYC, but they do have them Upstate and I stock up everytime I'm up there
they pack a wonderful vinegary and highly garlicky punch!
Reply

AL

7-28-2006 @12:13PM AL said... They are cheap, but I like Mt. Olive. Though their Sour Dills even make a die hard sour freak like me get a pucker face.
Reply

Cheryl

7-29-2006 @2:24PM Cheryl said... I second the vote for Nathan's pickles. I've only found them once, but they're the best grocery store pickles I've tried.
Reply

vanessa

7-31-2006 @3:18PM vanessa said... Strub's full sour kosher dills are my number one favourite, blow the rest of the competition out of the briney water.

(it's a canadian company)


Reply

11 Comments / 1 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links