Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Hot on HuffPost Food:

See More Stories
Tell us what you think for a chance at $1000!


Natural peanut butter makes me gag

I grew up in a household that modelled itself on slow food principles long before it became a fashionable food trend. Cereal came in plastic bags, my mom frowned upon canned and processed foods, we had a garden, we ate...natural peanut butter. Blerf. My little kid fantasy was to be able to eat stripey, Smucker's Goober Grape like all of my friends. (Have you tried it recently? It's foul.) Instead, we ate wallpaper paste made from freshly ground peanuts. And the absolute worst was when the oil would separate and get all over eve. ry. thing when I was trying to make a sandwich.

Don't get me wrong: I love me some peanut butter. Especially with seedless blackberry jam. (Europeans are collectively gagging right now, right?) When I was pregnant, I couldn't get enough of the stuff. But my choice in a happy medium between chunky glue and transfatty goodness. I like Adam's No-Stir.  It doesn't contain transfats, it doesn't need to be stirred (peeve), and it doesn't have any of that nasty oil on top. (If there is some, I pour it off.) Even when stored in the fridge it remains spreadable, but I like to keep my Adam's in the cupboard. Anyone else hate fresh-ground peanut butter glue? Or am I alone?

Filed Under: Raves & Reviews, Food Quest, Ingredients
Tags: adam's no stir, breakfast, comfort food, condiments, Food Quest, goober grape, lunch, peanut butter, PeanutButter, tranfats, trans fats, west coast

Sponsored Links

Reader comments (Page 1 of 1)

Kelly

10-23-2008 @12:50PM Kelly said... Adams no-stir may have no added sugar, but it does have hydrogenated oils... not healthy in my book! I love the taste of all-natural, even though I have to stir it - it's the natural oils, that's why! And my tip - don't try spreading natural PB on white bread. Use whole grain hearty bread and the PB won't tear it apart. Oh and keep it upside down in the refrigerator (even before mixing it - this helps to mix it up for you).
Reply

newbroom

5-19-2006 @6:54AM newbroom said... I arrived @ this site searching for analysis of Skippy's Natural....something I've tasted and dislike...

My local supermarket has it's own brand of freshly ground peanuts....the oil will seperate at room temp...but...when the peanuts are fresh and freshly ground...w/o any additives....you're getting the best of the peanut...no salt, no sugar, and most of all...no hydrogenation....you become accustomed to this pure butter and it is delectable.
(you're already 'accustomed' to hydrogenated peanut butter w/salt and sugar...it takes a bit of practice)

Smucker's is ok, and it is a chore to incorporate the naturally occurring oil which seperates, but...once you've got that accomplished...refrigerate and enjoy...(Smuckers has salt added)
Reply

Jana

6-07-2006 @6:34PM Jana said... I have found that I can easily incorporate the oil at the top of Smucker's Natural using an electric hand mixer. Remove one of the beaters and hold the jar firmly. It mixes quickly and the oil does not separate if stored in the refrigerator.
Reply

Alex

11-15-2006 @7:39AM Alex said... This is sort of peanut butter related...
Reply

matt

11-20-2007 @8:25AM matt said... can i use one of ur images for my school project
Reply

DanGarion

1-12-2006 @12:33PM DanGarion said... The fresh ground up stuff is pretty tough at times. I've tried the different varieties they have at Trader Joes, Peanut, Almond, Cashew, but then I found a Skippy Natural style that is a no stir, but I think it only comes in creamy. There is no trans fat though, so that's a plus!
Reply

SleighBoy

1-12-2006 @1:14PM SleighBoy said... This is sort of peanut butter related...



I made the mistake once of thinking that "Cashew Butter" (maybe it was called "Cashew Nut Butter", I don't remember) would be a good thing to try. After all, I enjoy cashews..



WRONG! It was as bland as homemade peanut butter, but with even LESS taste! Perhaps their are recipies for making it that include adding a pleasant taste.
Reply

SleighBoy

1-12-2006 @1:18PM SleighBoy said... In reference to my previous comment.. I do know the proper use of there/their.. I just made a mistake. :)
Reply

suburban misfit

1-12-2006 @1:46PM suburban misfit said... Yeah, the fresh-ground stuff isn't for me. I like the natural pbs that are sweetened with honey. Yum! My kids don't know the difference between those and Jiff. And they spread just fine!
Reply

Myron

1-12-2006 @1:56PM Myron said... Natural PB sucks for a kid but I like it as an adult, especially spread on apple slices. It seems nice and salty. Maybe the lack of sugar makes the salt more pronounced. I'm talking about the Whole Foods house brand in a jar. Stir it up and then put it in the fridge. When its cold it will stay mixed longer.



Now to totally blow your mind: Save leftover pancakes for a PB&J sandwich later in the day. Decadent.
Reply

Bubbles

1-12-2006 @2:08PM Bubbles said... My mom was a health-food nut, so she always got us the Laura Scudders 2-ingredient (peanuts, salt) peanut butter. Get this: to make it lower-fat, she would pour off the oil on the top of a new jar rather than stir it in. Try spreading that onto your seven-grain bread! One of the first things in my pantry when I grew up was the Goober grape, which I immediately realized was a fantasy that should have stayed in my childhood. I now hate peanut butter.
Reply

michelle

1-12-2006 @4:48PM michelle said... Oh, I love Adam's No-Stir. I discovered it a few months ago, actually. As a kid, I grew up on Skippy. I was a peanut butter for the masses, skippy/peter pan/jiff kind of girl.



Then I met my boyfriend who would only eat the natural, oil on top, stir it up kind. Which is super gross, imho. The Adams No-Stir is a good compromise. It's creamy and all together for me and natural/healthy for him.
Reply

Frank

1-12-2006 @8:29PM Frank said... I personally don't mind the all natural stuff. I actually grew up on the trans-fatty kind (on Wonder Bread of course) and only recently converted to the oil on top kind. I just turn a brand new jar upside-down overnight and the oil somewhat reincorporates; this makes it much easier to stir up. I store it in the fridge and it stays together pretty well long-term.



I now enjoy it on whole grain bread, and feel pretty virtuous health-wise about the whole business.
Reply

13 Comments / 1 Pages

Most Popular Stories

  • FDA Still Struggling to Define

    FDA Still Struggling to Define "Gluten-Free"Read More

  • This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg Itself

    This Omelet Recipe Is Written On the Egg ItselfRead More

  • Why Jewish Food Disappoints

    Why Jewish Food DisappointsRead More

Latest Flickr Feed


Sponsored Links