I saw a poll on television this morning, about what people do with their holiday leftovers. Some people make a turkey soup out of the meat, some people eat the turkey cold out of a bowl, some people make another meal out of it like hash or whatever. And I'm not sure but I think some people fix holes in their driveway with it, if they keep it in the fridge for more than a week. But the most overwhelming response came from people who make turkey sandwiches out of the leftovers. And if you're like me, it's not the next day but later that night, when you come home tired from dealing with a large family gathering, a bottle of wine, and eating two helpings of dinner.
So how exactly should you make the turkey sandwich? Read on...
To be honest, what follows is a personal recipe. Your set-up may vary, depending on the ingredients you do or do not like. But a turkey sandwich is universal up to a point, so let's start with the item that you simply can't skimp on: the bread.
Growing up my family ate Wonder Bread and only Wonder Bread. I don't even think I knew any other breads existed until I was around 18 years old. I even decorated my Easter eggs using the funky blue and purple spots (balloons?) on the package. But I digress. My point is Wonder Bread is fairly useless for sandwiches. Peanut butter and jelly is a nightmare, and a heavy sandwich like turkey is almost as bad. So go with something sturdy; slightly soft and cushiony, but strong and hearty. Maybe a Canadian White or one of the heartier Pepperidge Farm brands or a nice Bouyea-Fassett. It's your own decision, but just make sure you can lift the sandwich without it falling apart.
The turkey: you might like it cold, but have you tried a hot turkey sandwich? You don't have to do anything elaborate. This is one of those times taht nuking it for a minute doesn't harm the meat. You should nuke the stuffing too (more on that below).
The stuffing: I'm one of these people who likes all kinds of stuffing, sort of like a person who likes all kinds of pizza (I'm one of those too). I like store bought Stouffer's as much as home made Apple and Cornbread stuffing or something even more exotic. But mushy bread-based stuffings aren't really the best choice for a sandwhich, so I usually go with something heartier (there's that word again). A friend of mine makes his family's Scottish recipe, which is made with oatmeal and slightly spicy sausage. It's absoutely fantastic. (I'll post the recipe here as Xmas approaches). Nuke this too (making sure that the sausage is cooked first, of course - don't do it in the bird).
Toppings/dressing: I'm a non-topping/non-dressing person when it comes to a turkey sandwich, but lots of people like to have gravy or mayo or cheese. I do put cranberry sauce on it, but I usually leave that on the side, because the turkey and stuffing make it difficult enough to hold anyway, so having it on the side to simply place on each bite of the sandwich usually works well.
But whatever you do, don't put lettuce on the damn thing like someone I know does. That's just crazy talk.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-28-2005 @ 4:42PM
B said...
I think your hot turkey sandwitch is missing an ingredient, the gravy. I usually leave the turkey cold but add plenty of hot gravy, which is handy cause I don't have a microwave.
Reply
11-28-2005 @ 5:14PM
Heidi said...
I have it only one way every year:
Start with Sourdough bread (both adds good tang, and wont fall apart - although this year I used Wheat Sourdough). Add cranberry sauce to both pieces of bread. Layer with big hunks of white turkey meat, and spread just a little mayo, and add some lettuce. Perfect turkey sandwich.
Reply
11-28-2005 @ 5:47PM
Huffy said...
The BEST part of leftover turkey has always been my Post-Thanksgiving-Dinner sandwich, made exactly this way come hell or high water: white sandwich bread (but not the "balloon" kind), lots of Best Foods mayo (don't even *think* of Miracle Whip!!), cranberry sauce and a touch of horseradish. Even if I'm still so full that I must waddle to the kitchen, I can't sleep that night until I've eaten my sandwich.
It's a tradition . . .
Huffy
Reply
11-28-2005 @ 7:26PM
Josh said...
Ultimate Turkey Sandwich
http://splendidtable.publicradio.org/recipes/sundaysuppers/nov_turkey.html
white bread + cream cheese + scallion + cranberry sauce + turkey + mustard + lettuce + mayonaise
Reply
11-29-2005 @ 11:44AM
Shad Genki said...
I always make Turkey Shepherd's Pie the day after Thanksgiving. I put some leftover dinner rolls in the bottom of a bowl, which are probably hard by now, and I dribble a little gravy on them. Then, I put some thick pieces of turkey on top. Then, some stuffing, more gravy, and then mashed potatoes. I heat the whole thing up in the microwave, and when it's done I put two slices of canned cranberry sauce on top. It's perfect at about Noon the day after Thanksgiving! ^_^
Reply
11-29-2005 @ 11:48AM
kevin said...
The bread _must_ be toasted.
Reply
11-29-2005 @ 1:59PM
Beth said...
Bob, your sandwich reminds me of sandwich served all year round at McNally's Tavern in Chestnut Hill, Pa. It is fresh roasted turkey, hot stuffing and cranberry sauce served on a variety of rolls. It was just featured on "The Secret Life of.."
My turkey sandwich is bread (whatever I have), turkey and a whole lotta Hellman's. Done.
Reply
11-30-2005 @ 3:16AM
Jim In Holland said...
I grew-up in the US and used to love turkey sammiches after Thanksgiving - it's the best part of the holiday to me!
I like the sandwich sweet, and this will do the trick: Start with a decent bread - I used to have a DAK break machine and their recipe book had a oatmeal bread with a hint of maple syrup in it - slice it thick. Then add a thin layer of stuffing and lightly toast the bread with the cornbread, bringing them both up to temp. Once out of the toasteroven, put a layer of drained cole slaw over the stuffing (in lieu of mayo), then layer on the turkey (warm it if you want) and some cranberry dressing, and then another thick slice of toasted bread.
Yum! We used to call it a "Slabwich" - a sandwich is just a sandwich, but a Slabwich is a hernia on a plate.
Reply